Skip to content
The Climate Litigation Database

Chevron U.S.A. Inc. v. Newsom

Chevron U.S.A. Inc. v. Newsom ↗

BCV22100636, BCV22100748, BCV21102380California Superior Court (Cal. Super. Ct.)2 entries
Filing Date
Document
Type
10/09/2026
Tentative ruling issued setting aside and remanding the California Geologic Energy Management Division’s (1) denials of permits for well stimulation treatments in 2021-2024 and (2) 2024 rule prohibiting approval of such treatments.
A California Superior Court issued a tentative ruling setting aside and remanding the California Geologic Energy Management Division’s (CalGEM’s) denials of permits for well stimulation treatments (WSTs), including hydraulic fracturing, between 2021 and 2024. The court’s ruling also vacated CalGEM’s 2024 rule prohibiting approval of WST permit applications. The court declared that CalGEM’s 2021–2024 policy of denying all WST permit applications was “an invalid underground regulation” under the Administrative Procedure Act. The court ruled that CalGEM violated Public Resources Code § 3160 by denying applications based on a “blanket policy” rather than conducting individualized reviews. The court further ruled that “the stated climate rationale was not the operative basis for the ban and that the ban originated in direction from the Governor’s office.” Regarding the 2024 rule, the court found that substantial evidence did not support CalGEM’s determination that a categorical WST ban was reasonably necessary to reduce greenhouse gas emissions because the rulemaking record did not show that CalGEM addressed its prior finding that banning WST would result in a net increase in emissions due to displacement of in-state production by imported oil. The court denied relief against Governor Newsom, finding that he was not a proper respondent in the challenge to the 2024 rule and that relief against the Governor was not necessary with respect to the “underground” ban because complete relief was granted against CalGEM.
Decision
03/17/2022
Filed