Skip to content
The Climate Litigation Database

In re Polar Bear Endangered Species Act Listing and § 4(d) Rule Litigation

Safari Club International v. Jewell ↗

13-142U.S.3 entries
Filing Date
Document
Type
10/07/2013
Safari Club International v. Jewell - decision
Certiorari denied.
Decision
07/29/2013
Petition for writ of certiorari filed.
A number of hunting groups and individuals filed a petition for writ of certiorari seeking Supreme Court review of the D.C. Circuit’s decision upholding the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service’s designation of polar bears as a threatened species under the Endangered Species Act.
Petition For Writ Of Certiorari
01/01/2008
Filed

In re Polar Bear Endangered Species Act Listing and Section 4(d) Rule Litigation ↗

11-5353United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia (D.C. Cir.)2 entries
Filing Date
Document
Type
06/18/2013
Opinion issued upholding importation ban.
The D.C. Circuit affirmed the district court’s decision. The D.C. Circuit agreed with the district court’s conclusions that the Endangered Species Act listing for the polar bear had the effect of designating the species as “depleted” for Marine Mammal Protection Act (MMPA) purposes; that once the MMPA import prohibitions were triggered, polar bears could no longer be imported under the MMPA’s trophy import authorization; and that the import prohibitions applied even to bears taken before the species was designated as depleted. The D.C. Circuit also rejected claims that FWS’s determination to bar importation of trophies was procedurally defective.
Decision
01/01/2008
Filed

In re Polar Bear Endangered Species Act Listing and Section 4(d) Rule Litigation ↗

11-5219United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia (D.C. Cir.)4 entries
Filing Date
Document
Type
03/01/2013
Opinion issued upholding listing.
The D.C. Circuit upheld the U.S. Fish and Wildlife’s (FWS's) “threatened” designation for polar bears under the Endangered Species Act as a result of climate change, holding that the FWS engaged in reasonable decision-making and adequately explained the scientific basis for its decision.
Decision
01/01/2008
Filed

In re Polar Bear Endangered Species Act Listing and § 4(d) Rule Litigation ↗

Misc. Action No. 08-0764 (EGS) / MDL Docket No. 1993United States District Court for the District of Columbia (D.D.C.)6 entries
Filing Date
Document
Type
10/17/2011
Memorandum opinion issued regarding Section 4(d) rule.
A district court in Washington, DC held that the Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) violated the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) but not the Endangered Species Act (ESA) when it issued a special rule specifying the protective mechanisms that applied to the polar bear as a result of its threatened status. In May 2008, the FWS listed the polar bear as threatened under the ESA and then issued a special rule that, among other things, addressed the threat of direct impacts to individual bears and their habitat from oil and gas exploration and development activities within the species’ current range. Environmental groups filed suit, arguing that the FWS purposely and unlawfully crafted the rule in such a way as to avoid addressing the threat of climate change and that the FWS cannot effectively provide for the conservation of the polar bear without addressing global greenhouse gas emissions. The court held that climate change poses unprecedented challenges of science and policy on a global scale that entitles the agency to great deference, and that, based on the evidence before it, the FWS reasonably concluded that the ESA is not a useful or appropriate tool to alleviate the particular threat to the polar bear from climate change caused by global greenhouse gas emissions. However, the court agreed with the environmental groups that the FWS violated NEPA by failing to analyze the potential environmental impacts of its special rule. The FWS was required to conduct at least an initial assessment to determine whether the rule warranted a full environmental impact statement.
Decision
10/17/2011
Memorandum opinion issued upholding importation ban.
The district court for the District of Columbia upheld FWS’s barring of the importation of polar bear trophies.
Decision
06/30/2011
Memorandum opinion issued upholding listing determination.
A federal district court dismissed challenges to the listing of the polar bear as a threatened species under the Endangered Species Act. Environmental groups had sued to have the bear classified as endangered, a more protective classification, while Alaska, hunting groups, and others had asked the court to block any listing. The court, deferring to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, which made the determination, held that plaintiffs failed to demonstrate that the agency acted irrationally in making its listing decision, noting that the agency considered more than 160,000 pages of documents and over 670,000 comment submissions before making its final decision.
Decision
11/04/2010
Memorandum opinion issued remanding to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.
The court remanded the listing rule to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service "for the limited purpose of providing additional explanation for the legal basis of its listing determination, and for such further action as it may wish to take in light of the Court’s finding that the definition of an 'endangered species' under the [Endangered Species Act] is ambiguous."
Decision

Safari Club International v. Kempthorne ↗

1:08-cv-01550United States District Court for the District of Columbia (D.D.C.)2 entries
Filing Date
Document
Type
09/08/2008
Complaint
01/01/2008
Filed

American Petroleum Institute v. Kempthorne ↗

1:08-cv-1496United States District Court for the District of Columbia (D.D.C.)3 entries
Filing Date
Document
Type
08/27/2008
American Petroleum Institute v. Kempthorne - complaint
Complaint filed.
Five business and industry trade groups challenged one paragraph of an interim final rule meant to protect polar bears under the Endangered Species Act. The trade groups contended that the interim rule subjected operations in Alaska to stricter permitting and regulations than in other states. The lawsuit did not challenge the listing of the polar bear as threatened.
Complaint
01/01/2008
Filed

State of Alaska v. Kempthorne ↗

1:08-cv-1352United States District Court for the District of Alaska (D. Alaska)3 entries
Filing Date
Document
Type
08/04/2008
State of Alaska v. Kempthorne - complaint
Complaint filed.
Complaint
01/01/2008
Filed

California Cattlemen’s Association v. Kempthorne ↗

1:08-cv-01689United States District Court for the District of Columbia (D.D.C.)5 entries
Filing Date
Document
Type
11/25/2008
Memorandum submitted in support of motion to dismiss.
Decision
11/25/2008
Motion To Dismiss
07/23/2008
Notice of intent to sue submitted to the Secretary of the Interior and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service concerning listing of the polar bear as a threatened species.
Notice Of Intent to Sue

Safari Club International v. Kempthorne ↗

1:08-cv-00881-EGSUnited States District Court for the District of Columbia (D.D.C.)2 entries
Filing Date
Document
Type
05/23/2008
Complaint filed.
Plaintiffs challenged the Fish and Wildlife Service’s (FWS’s) barring of the importation of polar bear trophies. In its 2008 rule listing the polar bear as a threatened species under the Endangered Species Act (ESA), FWS had also determined that the listing had the effect of designating the species as “depleted” under the Marine Mammal Protection Act (MMPA), and that the MMPA thus barred continued importation of sport-hunted polar bear trophies. 
Complaint
01/01/2008
Filed

Center for Biological Diversity v. Kempthorne ↗

08-cv-1339United States District Court for the Northern District of California (N.D. Cal.)16 entries
Filing Date
Document
Type
12/04/2008
Action transferred to the District of the District of Columbia to be coordinated or consolidated with other pending actions.
Decision
11/18/2008
Order issued granting in part motions for leave to intervene by industry trade groups.
A number of additional industry groups moved to intervene in the case. The plaintiffs did not challenge the motions, but requested that the intervenors’ involvement in the case be subject to certain limitations. The court ruled that the groups could intervene with respect to the plaintiffs’ Endangered Species Act claims challenging DOI’s decision to classify the polar bear as a threatened species, but not with respect to plaintiffs’ claims that DOI did not comply with the National Environmental Policy Act or the Administrative Procedure Act in doing so.
Decision
10/20/2008
Order issued granting Defenders of Wildlife's motion for leave to intervene.
Decision
10/10/2008
Order issued on motions to transfer.
The court denied intervenor-defendant Arctic Slope Regional Corporation's motion to transfer the action to the District of Alaska and took under submission the federal defendants' motion to transfer to the District of the District of Columbia.
Decision