Skip to content
The Climate Litigation Database

Washington Farm Bureau v. Washington State Department of Ecology

Washington Farm Bureau v. Washington State Department of Ecology ↗

103413-0Washington Supreme Court (Wash.)4 entries
Filing Date
Document
Type
06/25/2026
Dismissal affirmed.
The Washington Supreme Court affirmed a lower court’s dismissal of a challenge by the Washington Farm Bureau (WFB) to a rule promulgated by the Washington State Department of Ecology implementing an exemption to the State’s cap-and-invest program. The program, established under the Washington Climate Commitment Act (CCA), “generally imposes caps on the amount of emissions from fuel suppliers but exempts fuel used exclusively for agricultural purposes … if the fuel buyer provides the seller with an exemption certificate.” To offset losses from the program, some suppliers implemented surcharges to the wholesale price of fuels. WFB requested declaratory judgment and review of agency action under Washington’s Administrative Procedure Act, claiming that the rule “failed to create a workable mechanism to receive CCA exemptions” and imposed an undue financial burden on the agricultural industry because of the surcharges. WFB further claimed that the Department exceeded its statutory authority and acted in an arbitrary and capricious manner in implementing the rule and wrongly denying its petition for rulemaking. The court determined that the plain language of the CCA indicates that the legislature intended for the Department to place the point of compliance on the suppliers, rather than the end users, making the method for claiming exemptions consistent with the law. Additionally, the court found that the regulation was not arbitrary and capricious because the Department acknowledged the challenges in applying the rule, considered alternatives, and determined that the chosen method was the most workable. The Department further demonstrated that it was not arbitrary and capricious in denying WFB’s request for rulemaking because it provided clear reasons for the denial.
Decision
06/18/2025
Response filed by Washington State Department of Ecology to opening brief.
Brief
04/14/2025
Brief
01/01/2023
Filed