Skip to content
The Climate Litigation Database

Arizona v. Mayorkas

Geography
Year
2021
Document Type
Litigation
Part of

About this case

Filing year
2021
Status
Stipulation of dismissal granted and claims dismissed with prejudice.
Geography
Docket number
2:21-cv-00617
Court/admin entity
United States → United States Federal Courts → United States District Court for the District of Arizona (D. Ariz.)
Case category
Federal Statutory Claims (US) → NEPA (US)
Principal law
United States → Administrative Procedure Act (APA)United States → National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA)
At issue
Lawsuit asserting that the Biden administration should have complied with the National Environmental Policy Act before changing course on immigration polices.
Topics
, ,  

Documents

Each case in our database can contain one or more documents.

Filing Date
Document
Type
Topics
02/28/2023
Stipulation of dismissal granted and claims dismissed with prejudice.
Decision
11/18/2022
Response filed by plaintiff in opposition to defendants' renewed motion to dismiss.
Opposition
Construction sectorPeople with limited assetsPeople on the moveBan+ 6 more
09/19/2022
Renewed partial motion to dismiss filed.
Motion To Dismiss
Construction sectorPeople with limited assetsPeople on the moveEnvironmental management sector+ 13 more
04/28/2022
Motion to dismiss granted in part and denied in part.
The federal district court for the District of Arizona granted in part the federal government’s motion to dismiss Arizona’s lawsuit contending that the federal government failed to comply with the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), acted arbitrarily and capriciously, and failed to comply with the Constitution’s Take Care Clause when the Biden administration took immigration-related actions to implement what Arizona called a “Population Augmentation Program.” Actions challenged included the halt of construction on the border wall and the rescission of the Migrant Protection Protocols (which required migrants who passed through Mexico on their way to the U.S. to remain in Mexico during immigrating proceedings). The State alleged that these actions would result in additional migrants entering the United States and Arizona, which would have a “direct and substantial impact on the environment in Arizona,” including increases in “the release of pollutants, carbon dioxide, and other greenhouse gases into the atmosphere, which directly affects air quality.” The court found that Arizona failed to state a claim that defendants violated NEPA by failing to prepare a programmatic environmental impact statement and also dismissed, on standing grounds, claims stemming from the termination of border wall construction due to a failure to establish that the termination caused the alleged injuries. The court alternatively found that the complaint failed to state NEPA or Take Care Clause claims with respect to the termination of border wall construction. The court allowed Arizona to amend its complaint to attempt to cure the deficiencies related to standing for the arbitrary-and-capricious challenge to the termination of border wall construction, but denied Arizona’s motion to conduct jurisdictional discovery. The court also directed the parties to file supplemental briefing on whether claims related to the MPP were moot due to intervening judicial decisions and Biden administration actions.
Decision
Construction sectorPeople with limited assetsPeople on the moveBan+ 7 more
04/15/2022
Tentative ruling provided in advance of motion hearing.
Decision
Construction sectorPeople with limited assetsPeople on the moveBan+ 5 more
02/07/2022
Motion for preliminary injunction denied.
The federal district court for the District of Arizona denied the State of Arizona’s motion for a preliminary injunction in the State’s lawsuit asserting that the federal government failed to consider the environmental impacts—including increased greenhouse gas emissions—of a collection of immigration policies that allegedly would cause the population of the U.S. and Arizona to increase. The court found that a 2021 Ninth Circuit decision foreclosed Arizona’s challenge under the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) to “an amalgamation of individual programs and policies.” The court also found that the same Ninth Circuit decision undermined Arizona’s challenge to the cessation of border wall construction because it cast doubt on “the so-called ‘enticement theory’ of environmental harm on which the State largely relies to establish causation.” The court also concluded it was unnecessary to consider a challenge to rescission of the Migrant Protection Protocols (which provided that individuals remain in Mexico during their immigration proceedings) because the Fifth Circuit already had upheld a permanent injunction requiring the overturning of the rescission.
Decision
Construction sectorPeople with limited assetsPeople on the moveBan+ 10 more
01/27/2022
Court issued tentative ruling that would deny motion for preliminary injunction.
Decision
Construction sectorPeople with limited assetsPeople on the moveGreenhouse gas+ 9 more
12/10/2021
Reply filed in support of motion to dismiss.
Reply
Construction sectorPeople with limited assetsBanPeople on the move+ 5 more
11/18/2021
Response filed by Arizona to motion to dismiss.
Response
Construction sectorPeople with limited assetsPeople on the moveFinance flow+ 6 more
10/15/2021
Reply filed in support of Arizona's motion for preliminary injunction.
Reply
Construction sectorPeople with limited assetsPeople on the moveGreenhouse gas+ 22 more
10/01/2021
Motion To Dismiss
Construction sectorPeople with limited assetsPeople on the moveGreenhouse gas+ 8 more
09/03/2021
Opposition filed by defendants to motion for preliminary injunction.
Motion
Construction sectorPeople with limited assetsPeople on the moveBan+ 23 more
07/12/2021
First amended complaint filed.
Complaint
People with limited assetsPeople on the moveConstruction sectorGreenhouse gas+ 24 more
04/11/2021
Complaint filed.
The State of Arizona filed a lawsuit in federal court in Arizona asserting that federal defendants should have complied with the National Environmental Policy Act before they changed course on immigration policies such as the border wall and halting the “Remain in Mexico” program. The State alleged that the policy changes would result in additional migrants entering the United States and Arizona, which would have a “direct and substantial impact on the environment in Arizona,” including increases in “the release of pollutants, carbon dioxide, and other greenhouse gases into the atmosphere, which directly affects air quality.” The State contended that population grown was a reasonably foreseeable consequence of the defendants’ actions and that the actions therefore should be held unlawful for failure to comply with NEPA.
Complaint
People with limited assetsPeople on the moveConstruction sectorJust transition+ 16 more

Summary

Lawsuit asserting that the Biden administration should have complied with the National Environmental Policy Act before changing course on immigration polices.

 Topics mentioned most in this case

See how often Topics get mentioned in this case and view specific passages of text highlighted in each document.

Group
Topics
Policy instrument
Risk
Impacted group
Just transition
Renewable energy
Fossil fuel
Greenhouse gas
Economic sector
Adaptation/resilience
Finance