Skip to content
The Climate Litigation Database

Astorga and Others vs. Environmental Assessment Service (SEA)

Geography
🇨🇱 Chile
Year
2021
Document Type
Litigation

About this case

Filing year
2021
Status
Decided
Geography
🇨🇱 Chile
Court/admin entity
Chile → Environmental CourtChile → Segundo Tribunal Ambiental
Case category
Suits against governments (Global) → Environmental assessment and permitting (Global) → Other projects (Global)
Principal law
Chile → Establishing Environmental Courts (Law No. 20.600)Chile → Establishing the Foundations of the Administrative Procedures Governing the Acts of the Bodies of the State Administration (Law No. 19.880)Chile → On General Bases of the Environment (Law No. 19.300)
Topics
, ,  

Documents

Each case in our database can contain one or more documents.

Filing Date
Document
Type
Topics
07/29/2024
Astorga and Others vs. Environmental Assessment Service (SEA) - decision
Decision from Supreme Court (in Spanish).
Decision
12/28/2023
Decisions from the Third Environmental Tribunal (in Spanish).
Decision
Extreme weatherConstruction sectorAdaptation/resilienceWater adaptation+ 36 more

Summary

On December 3, 2021, the claimants filed a judicial complaint under Article 17, No. 6 of Law No. 20.600 against Resolution Exenta No. 202199101608, issued on October 20, 2021, by the Committee of Ministers. This resolution rejected an administrative complaint against Resolution Exenta No. 12 (RCA), which had granted environmental approval for the “Concesión Vial Puente Industrial” project in the Biobío Region. The claimants contended that the project failed to adequately consider risks outlined in Article 11 of Law No. 19.300, including public health (letter a), adverse effects on water and soil (letter b), disruption of human systems and customs (letter c), and impacts on cultural heritage and environmental values (letter d). They also asserted that climate change scenarios were insufficiently evaluated, particularly concerning effects on water resources, natural systems, and extreme precipitation events.

The Committee of Ministers defended its decision, arguing that all observations had been reviewed and addressed. They stated that SEIA regulations do not explicitly require the consideration of climate change, but that the most adverse simulated scenarios indirectly accounted for it by addressing concerns about maximum precipitation and water flow. Additionally, they dismissed the need for indigenous consultation, stating that no culturally significant sites or indigenous resources were affected. They highlighted sufficient mitigation measures for impacts on the Los Batros wetland, including fauna relocation and horticultural compensation, while maintaining that the project complies with legal and environmental standards.

On December 28, 2023, the Environmental Tribunal rejected the claimants' judicial challenge. The tribunal found the administrative process generally adequate, noting a minor procedural deviation regarding the lack of evaluation of cumulative and synergistic effects on soil, but ruled this deviation insufficient to invalidate the resolution. It confirmed that public observations concerning health risks, climate change, and wildlife were properly addressed under Law No. 19.300 and SEIA regulations. The tribunal also dismissed the need for indigenous consultation and determined there were no significant impacts on the Los Batros wetland, cultural heritage, or human activities systems.

On January 17, 2024, a group of claimants filed a cassation recourse on the merits against this ruling. However, on July 29, 2024, the Supreme Court declared the recourse inadmissible due to a clear lack of legal grounds.

 Topics mentioned most in this case

See how often Topics get mentioned in this case and view specific passages of text highlighted in each document.

Group
Topics
Policy instrument
Risk
Impacted group
Just transition
Renewable energy
Economic sector
Adaptation/resilience
Finance