Skip to content
The Climate Litigation Database

Azienda Agro-Zootecnica Franchini Sarl v. Regione Puglia

Geography
International
Year
2007
Document Type
Litigation

About this case

Filing year
2007
Status
National legislation is consistent with EU policy
Geography
International
Court/admin entity
European Union → European Court of Justice
Case category
Suits against governments (Global) → Environmental assessment and permitting (Global) → Renewable projects (Global)
Principal law
European Union → Secondary Law → Directives → Council Directive 79/409/EEC of April 2, 1979, on the conservation of wild birdsDirectives → EU Habitats Directive (92/43/EEC)Directives → Renewable Energy Directive (2009/28/EC)
Topics
, ,  

Documents

Each case in our database can contain one or more documents.

Filing Date
Document
Type
Topics
07/21/2011
Eolica di Altamura acquired rights for a construction project of a wind farm thus submitted application for (i) environmental compatibility and (ii) confirmation that Regione Puglia had no objection for the project to be carried out in the protected Alta Murgia National Park. These applications were rejected on the grounds that the location was ‘totally inappropriate’ under Council Directives 92/43/EEC and 79/409/EEC (the Birds and Habitats Directives), and the absence of regulatory plans for wind power plants was regarded as ‘unsuitable’. The applicants referred this to the Regional Administrative Court of Apulia, who upheld the applications and annulled the regulatory provisions by which the Regione Puglia had imposed an absolute prohibition on the construction of wind power plants in the protected area. Whilst the decision of the Administrative Court was pending, Regione Puglia approved Regional Regulation No 15 of 18 July 2008, which was similarly directed at conservation measures within the terms of the annulled provisions. These proceedings were eventually stayed so the applicants sought reference for a preliminary ruling as to whether Italy’s national legislation absolutely prohibiting the construction of wind turbines in the national park is consistent with EU’s energy policy, which promotes renewable energy to combat climate change and comply with the Kyoto Protocol. The applicants wanted to assess whether it was instead appropriate to require an appropriate environmental impact assessment to be carried out to analyze the impact of an individual project on the site affected. The ECJ found no evidence that the prohibition hindered renewable energy production at the national or regional level as the prohibition solely applied to new wind turbines for commercial purposes rather than wind power plants with up to 20kW capacity, intended for self-consumption. The ECJ therefore determined that the prohibition was consistent with EU energy policy goals on the condition that the principles of non-discrimination and proportionality are respected.
Decision
Energy supply mitigationRenewable energyBanEnergy supply sector+ 5 more
04/14/2011
Decision
Energy supply mitigationRenewable energyEnergy supply sectorBan+ 12 more

Summary

Eolica di Altamura acquired rights for a construction project of a wind farm thus submitted application for (i) environmental compatibility and (ii) confirmation that Regione Puglia had no objection for the project to be carried out in the protected Alta Murgia National Park. These applications were rejected on the grounds that the location was ‘totally inappropriate’ under Council Directives 92/43/EEC and 79/409/EEC (the Birds and Habitats Directives), and the absence of regulatory plans for wind power plants was regarded as ‘unsuitable’.

The applicants referred this to the Regional Administrative Court of Apulia, who upheld the applications and annulled the regulatory provisions by which the Regione Puglia had imposed an absolute prohibition on the construction of wind power plants in the protected area. Whilst the decision of the Administrative Court was pending, Regione Puglia approved Regional Regulation No 15 of 18 July 2008, which was similarly directed at conservation measures within the terms of the annulled provisions.

These proceedings were eventually stayed so the applicants sought reference for a preliminary ruling as to whether Italy’s national legislation absolutely prohibiting the construction of wind turbines in the national park is consistent with EU’s energy policy, which promotes renewable energy to combat climate change and comply with the Kyoto Protocol. The applicants wanted to assess whether it was instead appropriate to require an appropriate environmental impact assessment to be carried out to analyze the impact of an individual project on the site affected. The ECJ found no evidence that the prohibition hindered renewable energy production at the national or regional level as the prohibition solely applied to new wind turbines for commercial purposes rather than wind power plants with up to 20kW capacity, intended for self-consumption. The ECJ therefore determined that the prohibition was consistent with EU energy policy goals on the condition that the principles of non-discrimination and proportionality are respected.

 Topics mentioned most in this case

See how often Topics get mentioned in this case and view specific passages of text highlighted in each document.

Group
Topics
Policy instrument
Renewable energy
Fossil fuel
Economic sector
Adaptation/resilience
Finance