Skip to content
The Climate Litigation Database

Borealis Polyolefine GmbH v. Minister for Land, Forestry, Environment, and Water Management

Geography
International
Year
2014
Document Type
Litigation

About this case

Filing year
2014
Status
Claims denied but corrections factor remanded
Geography
International
Court/admin entity
European Union → European Court of Justice
Case category
Suits against governments (Global) → GHG emissions reduction and trading (Global) → EU ETS (Global)
Principal law
European Union → Secondary Law → Directives → 2003/87/EC
Topics
, ,  

Documents

Each case in our database can contain one or more documents.

Filing Date
Document
Type
Topics
04/28/2016
After being allocated fewer free allowances than expected under the EU ETS, three industrial firms brought local actions against their allocations, claiming that the method used to calculate the correction factor was unlawful because it was based on Commission Decisions 2011/278 and 2013/448 which, they claimed, are in part invalid. The Court referred these Decisions to the ECJ to examine their validity, and subsequently the lawfulness of the correction factor. The ECJ rejected arguments from the firms—one German, one Dutch, and one Italian—that they should be granted a larger number of free greenhouse gas emission allowances under the EU ETS. The Court also instructed the European Commission (EC) to revise its approach to determining how many free allowances to grant—a step that has injected uncertainty into the markets built on the EU ETS. Several features of the ETS are critical to the case: 1. some allowances are auctioned to emitters and others are given away for free; 2. there are a fixed proportion of free allowances, which are granted only to firms that face competition from non-EU firms—a category that excludes electricity generators; 3. the process for calculating the number of allowances—auctioned and free—begins with Member States’ submission of emission sources and estimated volumes; and 4. in response to Member States’ overestimation of the allowances due to their industrial firms, the European Commission issued Decisions in 2011 and 2013 to govern the calculation of a “correction factor.” The ECJ found that the EC’s 2013 Decision established a “correction factor” calculation that ignored relevant information, and on that basis instructed the EC to revise its approach by March 2017. The ECJ’s ruling largely ratified the November 2015 recommendation issued in the case by Advocate General Kokott but deviated in one important respect: whereas Kokott had concluded that too many free allowances were granted to the firms, the ECJ determined that it was unclear whether too many or too few had been granted.
Decision
Greenhouse gasFinance flowTradable permitCarbon dioxide+ 13 more
11/12/2015
Decision
Tradable permitEnergy supply mitigationGreenhouse gasEnergy supply sector+ 17 more

Summary

After being allocated fewer free allowances than expected under the EU ETS, three industrial firms brought local actions against their allocations, claiming that the method used to calculate the correction factor was unlawful because it was based on Commission Decisions 2011/278 and 2013/448 which, they claimed, are in part invalid. The Court referred these Decisions to the ECJ to examine their validity, and subsequently the lawfulness of the correction factor.

The ECJ rejected arguments from the firms—one German, one Dutch, and one Italian—that they should be granted a larger number of free greenhouse gas emission allowances under the EU ETS. The Court also instructed the European Commission (EC) to revise its approach to determining how many free allowances to grant—a step that has injected uncertainty into the markets built on the EU ETS. Several features of the ETS are critical to the case:

1. some allowances are auctioned to emitters and others are given away for free;
2. there are a fixed proportion of free allowances, which are granted only to firms that face competition from non-EU firms—a category that excludes electricity generators;
3. the process for calculating the number of allowances—auctioned and free—begins with Member States’ submission of emission sources and estimated volumes; and
4. in response to Member States’ overestimation of the allowances due to their industrial firms, the European Commission issued Decisions in 2011 and 2013 to govern the calculation of a “correction factor.”

The ECJ found that the EC’s 2013 Decision established a “correction factor” calculation that ignored relevant information, and on that basis instructed the EC to revise its approach by March 2017. The ECJ’s ruling largely ratified the November 2015 recommendation issued in the case by Advocate General Kokott but deviated in one important respect: whereas Kokott had concluded that too many free allowances were granted to the firms, the ECJ determined that it was unclear whether too many or too few had been granted.

 Topics mentioned most in this case

See how often Topics get mentioned in this case and view specific passages of text highlighted in each document.

Group
Topics
Target
Policy instrument
Risk
Impacted group
Just transition
Fossil fuel
Greenhouse gas
Economic sector
Adaptation/resilience
Finance