- Climate Litigation Database
- /
- Search
- /
- United States of America
- /
- California v. EPA
California v. EPA
Geography
Year
2021
Document Type
Litigation
Part of
About this case
Filing year
2021
Status
Petitions for review denied.
Geography
Docket number
21-1018
Court/admin entity
United States → United States Federal Courts → United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia (D.C. Cir.)
Case category
Federal Statutory Claims (US) → Clean Air Act (US)
Principal law
United States → Clean Air Act (CAA)
At issue
Challenge to aircraft greenhouse gas standards adopted by EPA.
Topics
, ,
Documents
Each case in our database can contain one or more documents.
Filing Date
Document
Type
Topics
06/30/2023
Petitions for review denied.
The D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals denied petitions for review challenging the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA’s) adoption of regulations that aligned emissions standards for domestic aircraft with “technology-following” standards promulgated by the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) rather than establish “technology-forcing” standards. As a threshold matter, the court determined that it had jurisdiction because at least one of the state petitioners—Massachusetts—had standing under Supreme Court precedent in the nearly factually identical Massachusetts v. EPA. On the merits, the D.C. Circuit first held that the applicable Clean Air Act provision did not mandate a technology-forcing approach and that the EPA regulation permissibly implemented the provision by aligning domestic regulations with ICAO standards. Second, the D.C. Circuit rejected the petitioners’ arguments that the regulation was arbitrary and capricious. The petitioners contended that EPA failed to account for climate change harms, failed to consider alternatives that would reduce greenhouse gas emissions, and failed to sufficiently consider impacts on minority and low-income populations and on federalism interests as required by two executive orders. The court found that EPA reasonably determined that the best way to reduce global greenhouse gas emissions was to align domestic standards with international standards and that, given this conclusion, it was not necessary for EPA “to exhaustively examine alternatives that departed from these standards.” The court also found that the two executive orders, which provided no right to judicial review, foreclosed the argument that EPA acted arbitrarily and capriciously by failing to comply with them.
Decision
Greenhouse gasAir pollution riskCodes and standardsTransportation and logistics sector+ 6 more
06/01/2022
Brief filed by amicus curiae Airlines for America in support of respondent U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.
Amicus Motion/Brief
Transportation and logistics sectorGreenhouse gasCodes and standardsFossil fuel+ 31 more
05/27/2022
Brief filed by intervenor-respondents.
Brief
Greenhouse gasCodes and standardsCarbon dioxideTransportation and logistics sector+ 15 more
05/06/2022
Brief filed by respondents.
Brief
Codes and standardsGreenhouse gasAir pollution riskTransportation and logistics sector+ 28 more
05/05/2022
Brief filed by amicus curiae International Council on Clean Transportation in support of environmental and state petitioners.
Amicus Motion/Brief
Transportation and logistics sectorGreenhouse gasCarbon dioxideAir pollution risk+ 19 more
03/23/2022
Brief filed by Thomas C. Jorling as amicus curiae in support of state and environmental petitioners.
Amicus Motion/Brief
Air pollution riskGreenhouse gasCodes and standardsTechnological impact+ 11 more
03/21/2022
Brief of amicus curiae International Council on Clean Transportation filed in support of environmental and state petitioners.
Amicus Motion/Brief
Transportation and logistics sectorGreenhouse gasCarbon dioxideAir pollution risk+ 19 more
02/28/2022
Opening brief filed by environmental petitioners.
Brief
Greenhouse gasTransportation and logistics sectorAir pollution riskCodes and standards+ 22 more
02/28/2022
Opening brief filed by state petitioners.
Brief
Greenhouse gasCodes and standardsTransportation and logistics sectorExtreme weather+ 23 more
12/20/2021
Parties filed joint proposal for briefing schedule and format.
Other
Greenhouse gasAir pollution riskExtreme weatherCodes and standards+ 7 more
12/02/2021
Cases returned to the active docket and motion to appear as amicus curiae granted.
The D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals returned cases challenging EPA’s aircraft greenhouse gas standards to its active docket on December 2, 2021 after EPA decided not to commence a reconsideration proceeding or new rulemaking. The standards are challenged by 12 states and the District of Columbia and by three environmental groups. The court also granted a motion by Airlines for America to file an amicus brief in support of EPA. The parties must submit a proposed briefing format by December 23.
Decision
12/02/2021
Motions for leave to intervene granted.
The court granted motions for leave to intervene filed by The Boeing Company and Aerospace Industries Association of America, Inc.
Decision
11/15/2021
Joint motion to govern further proceedings filed.
Motion
Codes and standardsGreenhouse gasAir pollution riskPublic sector+ 1 more
08/17/2021
Environmental petitioners filed statement of non-opposition to joint motion to continue abeyance.
Statement
Codes and standardsGreenhouse gasAir pollution risk
08/16/2021
Joint motion to continue abeyance filed by state petitioners and EPA.
Motion
Greenhouse gasCodes and standardsAir pollution riskPublic sector+ 1 more
08/04/2021
Motion for leave to appear as amicus curiae in support of respondent filed by Airlines for America.
Amicus Motion/Brief
Greenhouse gasCarbon dioxideTransportation and logistics sectorCodes and standards+ 22 more
02/17/2021
Motion filed by federal respondents to hold cases in abeyance pending implementation of executive order and conclusion of potential reconsideration.
Motion
Fossil fuelCodes and standardsGreenhouse gasOil+ 21 more
02/17/2021
Abeyance motion granted.
The D.C. Circuit granted EPA’s motion to hold cases challenging the greenhouse gas standards for aircraft in abeyance while EPA reviews the standards pursuant to Executive Order 13990. The D.C. Circuit directed that the cases be held in abeyance pending further order of the court. EPA must file status reports every 90 days.
Decision
02/16/2021
Motion for leave to intervene on behalf of respondent filed by Aerospace Industries Association of America, Inc.
Motion To Intervene
Greenhouse gasCarbon dioxideTransportation and logistics sectorCodes and standards+ 5 more
02/16/2021
Motion for leave to intervene in support of respondent filed by The Boeing Company.
Motion To Intervene
Greenhouse gasCarbon dioxideCodes and standardsTransportation and logistics sector+ 6 more
02/11/2021
Statement of issues filed by state petitioners.
Statement
Codes and standardsGreenhouse gasAir pollution riskPeople with limited assets+ 3 more
01/15/2021
Petition for review filed.
Petition
Greenhouse gasCarbon dioxideTransportation and logistics sectorCodes and standards+ 10 more
Summary
Challenge to aircraft greenhouse gas standards adopted by EPA.
Topics mentioned most in this case
See how often Topics get mentioned in this case and view specific passages of text highlighted in each document.
Group
Topics
Target
Policy instrument
Risk
Impacted group
Just transition
Renewable energy
Fossil fuel
Greenhouse gas
Economic sector
Adaptation/resilience
Finance