The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AATA) set aside a decision by the Domestic Offsets Integrity Committee (DOIC) to refuse to endorse a proposal by Charles IFE Pty Ltd (CIPL) to vary a methodology determination under the Carbon Credits (Carbon Farming Initiative) Act 2011 (CCCFI Act). The specific variation proposed by CIPL was to delete a requirement in the "Carbon Credits (Carbon Farming Initiative) (Destruction of Methane from Piggeries using Engineered Biodigesters) Methodology Determination 2013" that engineered biodigesters used in a project must have been replaced or installed after 1 July 2010.
CIPL argued that this requirement punished early adopters of innovative technologies like themselves, who had commissioned a methane capture system in 1990, and created a commercial disadvantage. They also noted that similar date restrictions were not present in other methodology determinations related to agricultural emissions, such as those for piggeries using covered anaerobic lagoons or dairy manure.
The DOIC argued that removing the date restriction would be inconsistent with the CCCFI Act's objectives, particularly the "abatement premise" and additionality. They submitted that the baseline calculation in the methodology assumed no prior greenhouse gas capture, and allowing CIPL's existing biodigester to qualify would mean granting credits for abatement already occurring before 2010, thus not representing a new reduction in emissions incentivized by the CFI scheme. The DOIC contended that this would not meet the offset integrity standards and would undermine the purpose of the CCCFI Act to increase carbon abatement relative to the status quo.
However, the Tribunal disagreed with the DOIC's position, finding that the scheme of the CCCFI Act is at odds with it. The Tribunal reasoned that the Act aims to create incentives for offsets projects that are not common practice. Projects involving the capture and combustion of methane from livestock manure are specified in the regulations for the purposes of the additionality test, indicating they are not considered common practice. The Tribunal stated that excluding "pathfinders" like CIPL, who had already adopted such practices, through a date restriction in the methodology determination would run counter to the additionality test they clearly pass. The Tribunal concluded that profitability in the absence of the scheme is irrelevant to the Act's objectives of incentivizing non-common practice abatement activities. Consequently, the Tribunal*set aside the DOIC's decision and substituted a decision endorsing CIPL's proposal to delete the 1 July 2010 requirement.
- Climate Litigation Database
- /
- Search
- /
- Australia
- /
- Charles IFE Pty Ltd v Domestic Offsets Integrity Commission
Charles IFE Pty Ltd v Domestic Offsets Integrity Commission
About this case
Filing year
2013
Status
Decided
Geography
🇦🇺 Australia
Court/admin entity
Australia → Administrative Appeals TribunalAustralia → Federal Court of Australia
Case category
Suits against governments (Global) → Environmental assessment and permitting (Global) → Other projects (Global)
Principal law
Australia → Carbon Credits (Carbon Farming Initiative Act) 2011 (CCCFI Act)
Topics
, ,
Documents
Each case in our database can contain one or more documents.
Filing Date
Document
Type
Topics
01/24/2014
The Tribunal has decided to:
1. set aside the decision of the Domestic Offsets Integrity Committee dated 20 June 2013 refusing to endorse the applicant’s proposal dated 19 April 2013 to vary the Carbon Credits (Carbon Farming Initiative) (Destruction of Methane from Piggeries using Engineered Biodigesters) Methodology Determination 2013 by deleting Requirement 2.3(1)(c); and
2. substitute a decision endorsing the applicant’s proposal dated 19 April 2013 to vary the Carbon Credits (Carbon Farming Initiative) (Destruction of Methane from Piggeries using Engineered Biodigesters) Methodology Determination 2013 by deleting Requirement 2.3(1)(c).
Decision
Greenhouse gasTradable permitMethaneEnergy supply mitigation+ 23 more
Summary
Topics mentioned most in this case
See how often Topics get mentioned in this case and view specific passages of text highlighted in each document.
Group
Topics
Policy instrument
Risk
Just transition
Renewable energy
Fossil fuel
Greenhouse gas
Economic sector
Adaptation/resilience
Finance