Skip to content
The Climate Litigation Database

Conservation Congress v. U.S. Forest Service

Geography
Year
2013
Document Type
Litigation
Part of

About this case

Filing year
2013
Status
Defendants' motion to dissolve the injunction and amend the judgment granted.
Geography
Docket number
2:13-cv-01977
Court/admin entity
United States → United States Federal Courts → United States District Court for the Eastern District of California (E.D. Cal.)
Case category
Federal Statutory Claims (US) → Endangered Species Act and Other Wildlife Protection Statutes (US)Federal Statutory Claims (US) → NEPA (US)
Principal law
United States → Administrative Procedure Act (APA)United States → Endangered Species Act (ESA)United States → National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA)United States → National Forest Management Act (NFMA)
At issue
Challenge to timber sale project in Mendocino National Forest that allegedly threatened Northern spotted owl.
Topics
, ,  

Documents

Each case in our database can contain one or more documents.

Filing Date
Document
Type
Topics
03/02/2018
Defendants' motion to dissolve the injunction and amend the judgment granted.
The court found that the supplemental NEPA analysis addressed the court's concerns. The plaintiff asked the court to find that the new alternatives analysis was flawed because it was arbitrarily and capriciously based on fire conditions likely to occur during 97th percentile weather conditions. The plaintiff argued that these "inflated" fire weather conditions were used as a basis for incorporating a "large old tree component" into timber sales specifications and that 90th percentile weather conditions had been used in an earlier assessment. The court noted that this was a new issue that exceeded the scope of the original order but nonetheless found that the U.S. Forest Service provided an adequate explanation for using the 97th percentile conditions, including that the shift to the higher percentile accounted for climate change and was judged to approximate 90th percentile conditions over the 20-year life of the project.
Decision
Forestry sectorTerrestrial riskMarginalized ethnicityIndigenous people+ 2 more
05/30/2017
Final judgment entered remanding for supplemental NEPA analysis and enjoining removal of any trees with 20 inches dbh or greater in implementing the Project.
Decision
Forestry sectorConstruction sectorEnergy supply mitigation
02/16/2017
Plaintiff's motion for summary judgment granted in part and denied in part.
The federal district court for the Eastern District of California granted summary judgment to the plaintiff on claims that the defendants had not performed an adequate alternatives analysis and had failed to take a hard look under the National Environmental Policy Act. The court rejected other claims, including that an environmental impact statement (EIS) was required. In evaluating the degree to which impacts on the environment were "highly uncertain" and thus weighed in favor of requiring an EIS, the court's order noted that a recovery plan for the Northern spotted owl had identified "uncertainties" associated with climate change, but the court said that the plaintiff did not "tailor its argument to the context of the Project at issue." The court stated: To an extent, the Court may infer from these generalities that aspects of the Project cross into uncertain territory. But the Court cannot conclude, without more, the degree that this Project’s possible effects on the human environment are highly uncertain."
Decision
Forestry sectorTerrestrial riskJust transitionSocial inclusion+ 12 more
10/13/2015
Second amended complaint filed.
A lawsuit filed in California federal court challenged the U.S. Forest Service's authorization of a large timber sale in Mendocino National Forest, which the plaintiff alleged would have adverse impacts on the Northern spotted owl, a species protected under the Endangered Species Act. The complaint included allegations that "[o]wl biologists theorize that Northern spotted owl populations in the Mendocino National Forest are particularly vulnerable to population declines associated with climate change, as these populations exist at the southern-most inland portion – the hottest and the driest portion – of the species’ range."
Complaint
Forestry sectorBanJust transitionSocial inclusion+ 13 more

Summary

Challenge to timber sale project in Mendocino National Forest that allegedly threatened Northern spotted owl.

 Topics mentioned most in this case

See how often Topics get mentioned in this case and view specific passages of text highlighted in each document.

Group
Topics
Policy instrument
Risk
Impacted group
Just transition
Fossil fuel
Greenhouse gas
Economic sector
Adaptation/resilience