- Climate Litigation Database
- /
- Search
- /
- United States of America
- /
- Cruz v. Garland
Cruz v. Garland
About this case
Filing year
2023
Status
Petition denied.
Geography
Docket number
23-1910
Court/admin entity
United States → United States Federal Courts → United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit (1st Cir.)
Case category
Adaptation (US) → Actions seeking adaptation measures (US)
Principal law
United States → Immigration and Nationality Act
At issue
Challenge to the Board of Immigration Appeals affirmance of an immigration judge’s denial of a Guatemalan man’s asylum application that was based on being a member of a “particular social group” defined as “climate refugees.”
Topics
, ,
Documents
Each case in our database can contain one or more documents.
Filing Date
Document
Type
Topics
07/01/2024
Petition denied.
The First Circuit Court of Appeals denied a petition by a citizen of Guatemala and his wife and minor son challenging the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) affirmance of an immigration judge’s denial of the Guatemalan man’s asylum application. The man claimed that he and his family were members of a “particular social group” (PSG) defined as “climate refugees” that was eligible for asylum. The immigration judge found that the PSG of climate refugees was “too amorphous” to be legally cognizable and did not evince its “social distinction within Guatemalan society”; that the man’s “fear of poor and impoverished conditions” was not sufficient to constitute a “well-founded fear of future persecution”; and that he did not establish a nexus between the asserted PSG and any allegedly persecutory “government action.” The BIA affirmed without an opinion. The First Circuit found that the man did not meet his burden to show that the “climate refugee” PSG was legally cognizable. The court found that “the Guatemalan government’s acknowledgement that some of its citizens have been internally displaced by climate change and natural disasters plainly is not, without more, sufficient evidence to compel the conclusion that such individuals are perceived collectively as a socially distinct group within Guatemala by either the Guatemalan government or Guatemalan society.” Although the petitioner pointed to “journalistic articles” regarding risks posed to the group, including malnutrition, the First Circuit found that he failed to point to evidence suggesting that the issues were “uniquely associated” with climate refugees. The First Circuit also rejected the petitioner’s “fallback contention” that the BIA erred by summarily affirming the immigration judge’s denial.
Decision
People with limited assetsPeople on the moveSocietal impactExtreme weather+ 2 more
Summary
Challenge to the Board of Immigration Appeals affirmance of an immigration judge’s denial of a Guatemalan man’s asylum application that was based on being a member of a “particular social group” defined as “climate refugees.”
Topics mentioned most in this case
See how often Topics get mentioned in this case and view specific passages of text highlighted in each document.
Group
Topics
Risk
Impacted group