Czech Republic v Poland (Mine de Turów)

The parties are: APPLICANT: Czech Republic DEFENDANT: Republic of Poland INTERVENER (in support of the applicant): European Commission The case concerns the operation of the Turów lignite mine that supplies lignite to the 1984 megawatt Turów power plant, both owned by the Polish Energy Group (PGE). Emitting almost 10 million tons of carbon dioxide each year, the plant has been on the EU’s list of power plants with the highest negative impact on climate for years. The axis of the dispute was the negative impact on groundwater in Czech Republic. In 1994, the mine obtained a concession to extract lignite until 2020. In 2015, it requested an extension of the concession for six years. According to the Polish legislation, the extension was possible without conducting an environmental impact assessment (EIA). In March 2020, the mine received the requested prolongation until 2026. On September 30, 2020, the Czech Republic took Poland to the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) under Article 259 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU), arguing that Poland’s extension of the concession was unlawful because no EIA had been conducted, as required by EU Directive 2011/92. The applicant claimed that the Republic of Poland’s actions were unlawful by: (i) allowing the extension by 6 years of the development consent for the extraction of lignite without conducting an EIA, (ii) excluding the public from the procedure for granting the consent for extraction, (iii) declaring the EIA decision to be immediately enforceable, (iv) failing to allow the intervention of the public and of the Czech Republic in the procedure, (v) failing to enable judicial review of the mining development consent granted, (vi) failing to publish the mining development consent granted. As such, Poland has failed to fulfil its obligations under Directive 2011/92. In February 2021, the Czech Republic asked the CJEU for interim measures, requesting the immediate closure of activities of the lignite mine. The CJEU granted the interim measures by Order of the Vice-President of the Court of 21 May 2021. However, Poland did not comply with that order. On September 20, 2021, the CJEU ordered Poland to pay the European Commission a penalty of EUR 500,000 per day from the date of notification until that Member State complies with the order. On February 3, 2022, the Court of Justice’s Advocate General (AG) Prita Pikamäe stated in his opinion that Poland had violated the EIA Directive. On February 4, 2022, the Czech Republic informed the CJEU that as a result of the settlement reached with Poland on the dispute, it waived all claims. Consequently, the court struck the case from the register by an order of the same date.