In July 2026, constitutional proceedings were initiated before the Constitutional Court of Guatemala challenging Ministerial Agreement No. 145-2026/SG, issued by the Ministry of Energy and Mines. The agreement established general guidelines for conducting a consultation with the Maya Ixil people of San Juan Cotzal, Quiché, concerning the Palo Viejo Hydroelectric Project, which began operating in 2012 without the prior Indigenous consultation required under International Labour Organization Convention No. 169.
The proceedings arose from the Ministry's attempt to establish a consultation process addressing the consequences of the project's authorization and operation, including potential mitigation, reparation, compensation, and community participation in project benefits. The applicants, including Empresa Agrícola San Francisco Cotzal, S.A., Agrícola Cafetalera Palo Viejo, S.A., and José Antonio Sánchez Boche, challenged the ministerial measure. The litigation raised questions concerning the Ministry's regulatory competence, legal certainty, and the legal requirements governing consultation with Indigenous peoples in relation to an already-operational hydroelectric installation.
On July 8, 2026, the Constitutional Court, by a three-to-two majority, granted provisional constitutional protection (amparo provisional) in consolidated proceedings Nos. 4625-2026 and 4626-2026 and suspended the effects of Ministerial Agreement No. 145-2026. The provisional order did not determine the merits of the constitutional challenge.
In a related proceeding, the Court granted provisional protection to the Asociación de Generadores de Energía Renovable on July 16, 2026, directing the President of Guatemala to exercise his supervisory authority over the Ministry of Energy and Mines concerning the consultation process.
The dispute illustrates legal tensions between renewable-energy infrastructure development, Indigenous participation rights, regulatory competence, and legal certainty. The July 8 order provisionally suspended the consultation framework without finally determining its legality or the scope of the government's consultation obligations. No final merits disposition has been verified as of November 3, 2026.
- Climate Litigation Database
- /
- Search
- /
- Guatemala
- /
- Empresa Agrícola San Francisco Cotzal, S.A. and Others v. Ministry of Energy and Mines (Palo Viejo Hydroelectric Project)
Empresa Agrícola San Francisco Cotzal, S.A. and Others v. Ministry of Energy and Mines (Palo Viejo Hydroelectric Project)
About this case
Filing year
2026
Status
Pending
Geography
🇬🇹 Guatemala
Court/admin entity
Guatemala
Case category
Suits against governments (Global) → Constitutional and administrative law (Global)Suits against governments (Global) → Energy transition governance (Global)Suits against governments (Global) → Free (Global)Suits against governments (Global) → Human Rights (Global) → Indigenous Groups (Global)Suits against governments (Global) → Just transition (Global)Suits against governments (Global) → prior and informed consultation (Global)Suits against governments (Global) → Renewable energy (Global)
Principal law
Guatemala → 1989 (No. 169)Guatemala → and ConstitutionalityGuatemala → Convention Concerning Indigenous and Tribal PeoplesGuatemala → Decree Number 1-86 of the National Constituent AssemblyGuatemala → Law on AmparoGuatemala → Ministerial Agreement Number 145-2026/SG of the Ministry of Energy and MinesGuatemala → Personal ExhibitionGuatemala → Political Constitution
Documents
Each case in our database can contain one or more documents.
Filing Date
Document
Type