Skip to content
The Climate Litigation Database

Federal Public Prosecutor’s Office v. Joel de Souza (Deforestation and climate damage in the PAE Antimary)

Geography
🇧🇷 Brazil → Amazonas
Year
2021
Document Type
Litigation

About this case

Filing year
2021
Status
Pending
Geography
🇧🇷 Brazil → Amazonas
Court/admin entity
Brazil → Amazonas → Amazonas Federal Court
Case category
Suits against corporations, individuals (Global) → Others (Global)
Principal law
Brazil → Federal Constitution of 1988Brazil → Forest Code (Law No. 12.651 of 2012)Brazil → ILO Convention 169 concerning Indigenous and Tribal Peoples (enacted by Decree No. 5.051 of 2004, later revoked by Decree No. 10.088 of 2019)Brazil → National Environmental Policy Act (Law No. 6.938 of 1981)Brazil → National Policy on Climate Change – PNMC (Federal Law No. 12.187 of 2009)Brazil → Paris Agreement (enacted by Federal Decree No. 9.073 of 2017)Brazil → UN Framework Convention on Climate Change - UNFCCC (enacted by Federal Decree 2652/1998)
Topics
, ,  

Documents

Each case in our database can contain one or more documents.

Filing Date
Document
Type
Topics
09/20/2024
Decision
Terrestrial riskFinance flowGreenhouse gasAdaptation/resilience+ 26 more
05/27/2022
Reply
Terrestrial riskFinance flowFinance and insurance sectorForestry sector+ 14 more
09/09/2021
Petition
Terrestrial riskGreenhouse gasMarginalized ethnicityFinance flow+ 39 more

Summary

On September 9, 2021, the Federal Public Prosecutor's Office (MPF) filed a Civil Public Action (CPA) against Joel de Souza for deforesting an area of 172.43 hectares between 2011 and 2020, in Boca do Acre, Amazonas. The MPF alleges that the defendant's occupation of the land was illegal because it was part of an Agro-Extractivist Settlement Project (PAE), owned and managed by the National Institute for Colonization and Agrarian Reform (INCRA) and occupied by traditional extractivist communities. This ACP is part of a set of 22 lawsuits filed by the MPF as a result of the investigation carried out in Civil Inquiry No. 1.13.000.001719/2015-49 into illegal deforestation carried out inside the Antimary Agro-Extractivist Settlement Project (PAE) but against different defendants. The lawsuit is based, among other things, on Brazilian environmental law concerning the constitutional protection of the environment, the accusation of deforestation, propter rem civil liability for environmental damage, including climate damage, and collective moral damages. It also mentions the unauthorized emissions of Greenhouse Gases (GHG) caused by the illegal deforestation of the area, calculated at 119,944.34 tons of carbon dioxide and which are directly related to the Brazilian State's departure from its climate goals, out of step with national and international commitments made by Brazil in the National Policy on Climate Change - PNMC (Federal Law 12.187/2009) and in the Paris Agreement (promulgated by Federal Decree 9.073/2017). Among other requests: (i) reparation for the damage caused by illegal deforestation; (ii) payment of compensation corresponding to intermediate and residual material environmental damage; (iv) payment of compensation corresponding to climate damage; and (v) payment of compensation corresponding to collective moral damage.

On May 27, 2022, the defendant filed a defense, alleging that he was not the owner or possessor of the area, having been a mere holder; he denied having caused environmental damage; he stated that, in 2018, “he acquired a herd of cattle in the region where the property is located, so that, as he was not the owner or possessor of any property in the area, he needed to rent/lease pastures for grazing said herd of cattle.” He, therefore, requested that the case be dismissed.

On September 20, 2024, the court ordered the defendant to (i) recompose the degraded area; (ii) pay compensation for material damages relating to interim and residual environmental damage, in an amount to be determined in the liquidation phase of the judgment; (iii) pay compensation for climate damage caused by deforestation, in the amount of R$3,298,469.42 and (iv) to pay compensation for collective moral damages of R$603,505.00. The ruling recognized the existence of climate damage, unlawful conduct, and a causal link, even though the defendant was not responsible for the deforestation but benefited from the damage caused by a third party. To calculate the value of the climate damage, US$ 5.00 per ton of CO2e was adopted, per Ordinance 176/2023.

An appeal is currently underway.

 Topics mentioned most in this case

See how often Topics get mentioned in this case and view specific passages of text highlighted in each document.

Group
Topics
Target
Policy instrument
Risk
Impacted group
Just transition
Greenhouse gas
Economic sector
Adaptation/resilience
Finance