Skip to content
The Climate Litigation Database

Fridays for Future Estonia vs. Environmental Board (Oil Shale Mining Case)

Geography
Year
2024
Document Type
Litigation

About this case

Filing year
2024
Status
Pending
Court/admin entity
EstoniaTallinn Administrative CourtEstoniaTallinn Circuit Court
Case category
Suits against governments (Global)Environmental assessment and permitting (Global)Utilities (Global)Suits against governments (Global)Human Rights (Global)Right to a healthy environment (Global)Youth/Children (Global)Suits against governments (Global)Protecting biodiversity and ecosystems (Global)
Principal law
EstoniaEnvironmental Code ActEuropean UnionEuropean Convention on Human RightsInternational LawEuropean Union EIA DirectiveInternational LawEuropean Union Habitats DirectiveInternational LawUN Convention on the Rights of the ChildInternational LawUNFCCCParis Agreement
At issue
Whether Scope 3 emissions should have been included in the EIA report for increasing oil shale (fossil fuel) excavation rate.

Documents

Filing Date
Document
Type

Summary

In 2019, the Environmental Board issued permits to two companies, Enefit Industry AS and Osaühingu VKG Kaevandused, to extract shale oil, a coal-like fossil fuel, at the Uus-Kiviõli sites until 2049. In October 2025, the Board amended the permits to increase the quantity of oil shale mined to a total of 15 million tonnes a year, or a 2.5-fold increase. MTÜ Loodusvõlu, the legally registered NGO of Fridays for Future Estonia, challenged this amendment, claiming that the Board had failed to assess the indirect climate impact of increased mining, caused by increased downstream greenhouse gas emissions from the processing of oil shale. Additionally, they claim that the Board also inadequately assessed the impacts of increased mining on nearby wetlands and wildlife, including species and sites protected under the EU Bird Directive and Habitat Directive. The Tallinn Administrative Court accepted the case and designated the Environmental Board as the defendant.