Skip to content
The Climate Litigation Database

Germany v. Nordzucker AG

Geography
International
Year
2009
Document Type
Litigation

About this case

Filing year
2009
Status
Resolved
Geography
International
Court/admin entity
European Union → European Court of Justice
Case category
Suits against governments (Global) → GHG emissions reduction and trading (Global) → EU ETS (Global)
Principal law
European Union → Secondary Law → Directives → 2003/87/EC
Topics
, ,  

Documents

Each case in our database can contain one or more documents.

Filing Date
Document
Type
Topics
04/29/2015
Nordzucker AG (Nordzucker), a sugar refinery operator in Germany, produced an emissions report for 2005 pursuant to Directive 2003/87/EC, part of the European Emissions Trading System (EU ETS). Nordzucker’s emissions report excluded emissions resulting from steam generation necessary to operate the refinery’s drying facility based on a letter from the German Ministry for the Environment stating that such facilities were exempted from compulsory emissions trading schemes. An expert verified the report, and Nordzucker surrendered emission allowances equal to the emissions stated in the report. Subsequently, the German Emissions Trading Authority examined Nordzucker’s emissions report and found that it should have included emissions attributable to the refinery’s drying facility. Nordzucker revised its emissions report and surrendered additional allowances. German authorities found Nordzucker liable for failing to timely surrender emission allowances and levied a penalty as provided in Article 16(3) of Directive 2003/87/EC. After a series of appeals, the German Federal Administrative Court referred to the ECJ the question whether excess emissions penalties apply where an operator surrenders allowances equal to emissions stated in a verified report, but where the report is later found to understate the operator’s emissions and additional allowances are surrendered. The ECJ found that such penalties should not apply and that, in such cases, national authorities should establish proportionate penalties considering relevant factual circumstances.
Decision
Greenhouse gasTradable permitFinance flowCarbon dioxide
02/05/2015
Nordzucker AG (Nordzucker), a sugar refinery operator in Germany, produced an emissions report for 2005 pursuant to Directive 2003/87/EC, part of the European Emissions Trading System (EU ETS). Nordzucker’s emissions report excluded emissions resulting from steam generation necessary to operate the refinery’s drying facility based on a letter from the German Ministry for the Environment stating that such facilities were exempted from compulsory emissions trading schemes. An expert verified the report, and Nordzucker surrendered emission allowances equal to the emissions stated in the report. Subsequently, the German Emissions Trading Authority examined Nordzucker’s emissions report and found that it should have included emissions attributable to the refinery’s drying facility. Nordzucker revised its emissions report and surrendered additional allowances. German authorities found Nordzucker liable for failing to timely surrender emission allowances and levied a penalty as provided in Article 16(3) of Directive 2003/87/EC. After a series of appeals, the German Federal Administrative Court referred to the ECJ the question whether excess emissions penalties apply where an operator surrenders allowances equal to emissions stated in a verified report, but where the report is later found to understate the operator’s emissions and additional allowances are surrendered. The ECJ found that such penalties should not apply and that, in such cases, national authorities should establish proportionate penalties considering relevant factual circumstances.
Decision
Tradable permitGreenhouse gasFinance flowCarbon dioxide+ 1 more

Summary

Nordzucker AG (Nordzucker), a sugar refinery operator in Germany, produced an emissions report for 2005 pursuant to Directive 2003/87/EC, part of the European Emissions Trading System (EU ETS). Nordzucker’s emissions report excluded emissions resulting from steam generation necessary to operate the refinery’s drying facility based on a letter from the German Ministry for the Environment stating that such facilities were exempted from compulsory emissions trading schemes. An expert verified the report, and Nordzucker surrendered emission allowances equal to the emissions stated in the report. Subsequently, the German Emissions Trading Authority examined Nordzucker’s emissions report and found that it should have included emissions attributable to the refinery’s drying facility. Nordzucker revised its emissions report and surrendered additional allowances. German authorities found Nordzucker liable for failing to timely surrender emission allowances and levied a penalty as provided in Article 16(3) of Directive 2003/87/EC. After a series of appeals, the German Federal Administrative Court referred to the ECJ the question whether excess emissions penalties apply where an operator surrenders allowances equal to emissions stated in a verified report, but where the report is later found to understate the operator’s emissions and additional allowances are surrendered. The ECJ found that such penalties should not apply and that, in such cases, national authorities should establish proportionate penalties considering relevant factual circumstances.

 Topics mentioned most in this case

See how often Topics get mentioned in this case and view specific passages of text highlighted in each document.

Group
Topics
Policy instrument
Greenhouse gas
Economic sector
Finance