Skip to content
The Climate Litigation Database

Helping Hand Tools v. EPA

Geography
Year
2014
Document Type
Litigation
Part of

About this case

Filing year
2014
Status
Order and amended opinion issued; petition for panel rehearing and petition for rehearing en banc denied.
Geography
Docket number
14-72553
Court/admin entity
United States → United States Federal Courts → United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit (9th Cir.)
Case category
Federal Statutory Claims (US) → Clean Air Act (US)
Principal law
United States → Clean Air Act (CAA)
At issue
Challenge to PSD permit for biomass-burning power plant at California lumber yard.
Topics
, ,  

Documents

Each case in our database can contain one or more documents.

Filing Date
Document
Type
Topics
12/23/2016
Order and amended opinion issued; petition for panel rehearing and petition for rehearing en banc denied.
Decision
Fossil fuelGreenhouse gasEnergy supply mitigationRenewable energy+ 22 more
12/14/2016
Response filed by EPA in opposition to rehearing.
EPA and the permittee for a biomass-fired power plant in California urged the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals not to grant a rehearing of its opinion upholding the plant’s Prevention of Significant Deterioration (PSD) permit. The Ninth Circuit had deferred to EPA’s application of its Guidance for Determining Best Available Control Technology for Reducing Carbon Dioxide Emissions from Bioenergy Production (Bioenergy BACT Guidance) and had also found that EPA reasonably concluded that the Clean Air Act did not require consideration of solar power and a greater natural gas mix as control alternatives at the facility. EPA said the “core” of the Center for Biological Diversity’s (CBD’s) petition for rehearing was “little more than a rehashing of its merits arguments” and that CBD’s arguments misconstrued EPA’s conclusions regarding the carbon dioxide contributions of different types of feedstocks. EPA also said that modification of the Ninth Circuit’s opinion’s statements about the Bioenergy BACT Guidance was not warranted.
Response
Greenhouse gasCarbon dioxideBioenergyEnergy supply mitigation+ 12 more
12/14/2016
Response filed by permittee in opposition to rehearing.
In opposition to the Center for Biological Diversity's (CBD's) petition for rehearing, the permittee argued that the Ninth Circuit had correctly applied the law and had correctly described CBD’s arguments.
Response
Energy supply mitigationRenewable energyBioenergyEnergy supply sector+ 7 more
10/14/2016
Petition for rehearing and/or modification of opinion filed.
The Center for Biological Diversity (CBD) filed a petition for rehearing and/or modification of opinion after the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals deferred to EPA and upheld a Prevention of Significant Deterioration (PSD) permit for a biomass-burning power plant at a lumber mill in California. CBD argued that the court had improperly applied deference to “unsupported and arbitrary” factual conclusions reached by EPA. CBD said that even if rehearing were not granted, the court should modify its “overbroad” conclusion that EPA’s Guidance for Determining Best Available Control Technology for Reducing Carbon Dioxide Emissions from Bioenergy Production (Bioenergy BACT Guidance) was rational. CBD also called for modification of the opinion to correct factual errors regarding prior environmental review of the facility and the final list of fuels EPA approved in the permit.
Petition For Rehearing
Energy supply mitigationRenewable energyGreenhouse gasBioenergy+ 33 more
09/02/2016
Opinion issued upholding permit.
The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld a Prevention of Significant Deterioration (PSD) permit for a biomass-burning power plant at a lumber mill in California. The Ninth Circuit concluded that the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) had reasonably concluded that the Clean Air Act did not require consideration of solar power and a greater natural gas mix as control alternatives at the facility because doing so would impermissibly “redefine the source.” The Ninth Circuit also deferred to EPA’s application of its Guidance for Determining Best Available Control Technology for Reducing Carbon Dioxide Emissions from Bioenergy Production (Bioenergy BACT Guidance). The court said that this case appeared to be the first time a circuit court had addressed EPA’s framework for evaluating BACT for greenhouse gas emissions from biomass facilities and concluded that deference to the Bioenergy BACT Guidance was required because EPA was acting “at the frontiers of science.”
Decision
Fossil fuelGreenhouse gasEnergy supply mitigationGas+ 22 more

Summary

Challenge to PSD permit for biomass-burning power plant at California lumber yard.

 Topics mentioned most in this case

See how often Topics get mentioned in this case and view specific passages of text highlighted in each document.

Group
Topics
Policy instrument
Risk
Renewable energy
Fossil fuel
Greenhouse gas
Economic sector
Adaptation/resilience
Finance