Skip to content
The Climate Litigation Database

Individual v. Municipality of Carrillo and Others

Geography
🇨🇷 Costa Rica
Year
2026
Document Type
Litigation

About this case

Filing year
2026
Status
Enforcement / Implementation Phase
Geography
🇨🇷 Costa Rica
Court/admin entity
Costa Rica → Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court of Costa Rica
Case category
Suits against governments (Global) → Human Rights (Global) → Right to a healthy environment (Global)
Principal law
Costa Rica → Constitution of Costa RicaInternational Law → American Convention on Human RightsInternational Law → UN Framework Convention on Climate Change
Topics
, ,  

Documents

Each case in our database can contain one or more documents.

Filing Date
Document
Type
Topics
04/28/2026
Judicial decision from Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court of Costa Rica. (SPANISH)
Decision
Extractive sectorZoning and spatial planningPublic sectorBan+ 39 more

Summary

A native of Filadelfia, Guanacaste, filed an amparo against the Municipalities of Carrillo and Liberia, the Ministry of Environment and Energy (MINAE), and other agencies. He alleged that the authorities tolerated mechanized and illegal sand extraction in the Tempisque River, which had caused erosion, harm to connected wetlands and riverbank species, and risks to Filadelfia’s retaining wall and of subsidence in the town. He also alleged that artisanal extractors who use ox carts face requirements designed for large-scale operations.

The respondents described their separate competences. MINAE’s Directorate of Geology and Mines (DGM) pointed to its zoning of the riverbed, its inspections, and a mechanized concession that it said operates within authorized limits several kilometers downstream of Filadelfia. The municipalities and the National System of Conservation Areas (SINAC) deferred to the mining authority, and the National Emergency Commission (CNE) stated that the situation did not constitute a national emergency.

On April 28, 2026, the Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court of Costa Rica granted the amparo against the DGM, the National Environmental Technical Secretariat (SETENA), SINAC, and both municipalities, and dismissed it against the CNE. It found “insufficient public protection” because each body acted within its own sphere, but none demonstrated an integrated, up-to-date, and coordinated response to the alleged cumulative risk to the river system. It reasoned that, under constitutional environmental law, a complex ecosystem cannot be left legally “without an owner” because responsibility is divided among specialized agencies. The administration bears a reinforced burden of technical justification, since the State is better placed than the petitioner to produce the technical record.

On its own initiative, it included a section on the Inter-American Court of Human Rights’ Advisory Opinion OC-32/25. It read the opinion as establishing reinforced State duties of mitigation, adaptation, prevention of significant environmental harm, regulation of polluting activities, business supervision, and protection of vulnerable groups, and as developing the pro natura principle (citing paragraphs 216 and 279–286). In the Chamber’s description, that principle requires the interpretation that gives the greatest protection to nature, ecosystems, and related human rights. In the national context, it added, decisions on matters such as natural resource use, land-use planning, water management, and coastal development must also be assessed in light of the State’s duty to prevent environmental and climate harm and must rest on scientific evidence and an assessment of cumulative impacts. It called the opinion a “normative parameter of high relevance” that expands the judicial enforceability of State climate action. When applying the law to the facts, however, it did not return to OC-32/25. It relied on OC-23/17 for the autonomous right to a healthy environment and the duty of prevention, and applied the precautionary principle as a constitutional decision standard.

The Chamber ordered four measures due within three months with a report back to it: an integrated public report by the DGM, coordinated with SETENA, SINAC, and the municipalities; a SETENA review of whether the assessment instruments for the area capture cumulative and synergistic impacts; a SINAC technical assessment of biodiversity, ecological connectivity, and wetlands; and effective territorial control by the municipalities. The State and both municipalities were ordered to pay costs and damages.

In its reasoning, it also called for regulating artisanal extraction in proportion to its scale, though the operative part contains no order on this point.

 Topics mentioned most in this case

See how often Topics get mentioned in this case and view specific passages of text highlighted in each document.

Group
Topics
Policy instrument
Risk
Impacted group
Just transition
Fossil fuel
Greenhouse gas
Economic sector
Adaptation/resilience
Finance