Skip to content
The Climate Litigation Database

INSAPROMA and National Committee for the Fight against Climate Change v. National Energy Commission et al.

Geography
Year
2025
Document Type
Litigation

About this case

Filing year
2025
Status
Decided
Geography
Court/admin entity
Dominican Republic → Superior Administrative Tribunal of the Dominican Republic → Fourth Chamber
Case category
Suits against governments (Global) → Energy and power (Global)Suits against governments (Global) → GHG emissions reduction and trading (Global)
Principal law
Art. 27Dominican Republic → Constitution of the Dominican Republic → Art. 67.3Dominican Republic → Law 1-12Dominican Republic → Law 112-00 on Hydrocarbons → Arts. 1 and 2Dominican Republic → Law 137-11Dominican Republic → Law 57-07 on Incentives for the Development of Renewable Energy Sources and their Special Regimes → Art. 21Dominican Republic → National Development Strategy 2030Dominican Republic → Organic Law of the Constitutional Court and Constitutional Procedures → Art. 104 → Art. 107 → Art. 108(g) → Art. 75 → Art. 85International Law → UNFCCC → Paris Agreement
Topics
, ,  

Documents

Each case in our database can contain one or more documents.

Filing Date
Document
Type
Topics
08/26/2025
Decision
Energy supply mitigationRenewable energyEnergy supply sectorFossil fuel+ 11 more

Summary

On April 23, 2025, the Institute of Lawyers for Environmental Protection (INSAPROMA) and the National Committee for the Fight against Climate Change filed a compliance amparo action (acción de amparo de cumplimiento) before the Superior Administrative Tribunal of the Dominican Republic. The defendants were the National Energy Commission, the Superintendency of Electricity, the Ministry of Industry, Commerce and MSMEs, the National Council for Climate Change and Clean Development Mechanism, the Ministry of Environment and Natural Resources, the Ministry of Energy and Mines, the President of the Republic, and the heads of each of these bodies.

The plaintiffs asked the court to order the defendants to comply with several provisions. These were Article 67.3 of the Constitution, which requires the State to promote non-polluting alternative energy; the Paris Agreement; and Article 27 of Law 1-12 on the National Development Strategy, which mandates decarbonization of the energy system. They also invoked the provision of Law 112-00 on Hydrocarbons that earmarks 5% of the fuel consumption tax for renewable energy, and Article 21 of Law 57-07, which sets a target of 25% renewable energy injection into the grid by 2025. In addition, they requested that the defendants provide documentation of compliance and pay a daily penalty of RD$100,000 for any delay. The plaintiffs argued that the government had acted contrary to these mandates by authorizing coal-fired power plants, bunker C power barges, and an 800 MW fossil gas project, and by granting fossil fuel tax exemptions. They relied on Inter-American Court of Human Rights Advisory Opinion OC-32/25 and the International Court of Justice advisory opinion on climate change.

The defendants raised several procedural objections. They argued that the plaintiffs lacked standing and that several agencies were not the authorities responsible for the obligations invoked. They also argued that the action lacked an object because the 2025 renewable energy target had already been met, and that the 5% earmark under Law 112-00 had been tacitly repealed by Law 253-12. Finally, they argued that the plaintiffs had not made the prior formal demand for compliance required by Article 107 of Law 137-11. On the merits, the defendants argued that the plaintiffs had not proven any non-compliance.

On August 26, 2025, the Fourth Chamber of the Superior Administrative Tribunal declared the action procedurally improper (improcedente) against all defendants under Articles 107 and 108(g) of Law 137-11. The court compared the plaintiffs’ prior notice of February 6, 2025, with the claims in the amparo petition. The notice had demanded compliance with Article 67.3 of the Constitution, Article 27 of Law 1-12, the Paris Agreement, and Articles 1 and 2 of Law 112-00. The petition added claims that the notice had not contained, including compliance with Law 57-07. Relying on Constitutional Court precedent that the prior demand must be express, categorical, and unequivocal, the court held that this inconsistency meant the plaintiffs had not satisfied the prior demand requirement. The court did not address the remaining objections or the merits. In particular, it did not decide whether climate obligations under the Paris Agreement and the Constitution can be enforced through a compliance amparo action.

 Topics mentioned most in this case

See how often Topics get mentioned in this case and view specific passages of text highlighted in each document.

Group
Topics
Target
Policy instrument
Renewable energy
Fossil fuel
Economic sector
Adaptation/resilience
Finance