Skip to content
The Climate Litigation Database

Kim et al. v. Minister of Land, Infrastructure and Transport

Geography
🇰🇷 South Korea
Year
2025
Document Type
Litigation

About this case

Filing year
2025
Status
Appealed / Under Review
Geography
🇰🇷 South Korea
Court/admin entity
South Korea → Seoul Administrative Court
Case category
Suits against governments (Global) → Environmental assessment and permitting (Global) → Utilities (Global)
Principal law
South Korea → Administrative Litigation ActSouth Korea → Carbon Neutrality Act
Topics
, ,  

Documents

Each case in our database can contain one or more documents.

Filing Date
Document
Type
Topics
01/15/2026
Decision
Greenhouse gasFossil fuelGasConstruction sector+ 32 more
03/01/2025
This is an administrative lawsuit brought by residents and climate advocacy groups against the Minister of Land, Infrastructure and Transport seeking to nullify or cancel the approval of the “Yongin Advanced System Semiconductor Cluster National Industrial Complex Plan” The plaintiffs argue that the project will substantially increase greenhouse gas emissions, exacerbate climate change, and infringe their constitutional and statutory rights to a safe and healthy environment. They rely on the Framework Act on Carbon Neutrality and Green Growth and environmental statutes, asserting that monetary compensation cannot remedy the irreversible harms of climate change. The plaintiffs contend that the project’s approval relied on deficient environmental and climate impact assessments that failed to account for the full lifecycle emissions of the industrial complex, including electricity demand and hydrogen co-firing limitations. They argue that the development breaches Korea’s national carbon reduction obligations, undermines the 1.5°C climate target, and ignores low-carbon alternatives such as stricter energy efficiency measures and renewable integration. They further assert that approving the project sets a precedent that weakens regulatory oversight and ESG commitments in industrial planning. The plaintiffs emphasize the broader consequences of the project’s emissions, estimating that it would add several million tons of CO₂ to national outputs, threatening local communities, future generations, and Korea’s climate commitments. On January 15, 2026, the Seoul Administrative Court recognized the plaintiffs’ standing to challenge the approval of the Yongin semiconductor cluster but dismissed their claims for a declaration of invalidity or, alternatively, cancellation of the approval. The significance of this holding lies in its recognition of a statutory basis for standing for residents outside the environmental impact assessment area, without requiring specific allegations or proof of environmental harm exceeding tolerable limits, in light of the widespread and unequal impacts of the climate crisis. The court interpreted the Framework Act on Carbon Neutrality and Green Growth as directly and specifically protecting individual citizens’ interests in climate action, including a legally protected interest in using administrative litigation to scrutinize whether climate response plans of national and subnational governments are properly implemented at the climate change impact assessment stage of development approvals. Its reasoning drew on the climate crisis’s widespread and unequal impacts, the Act’s guarantees of procedural participation and access to information, and the role of climate change impact assessments in achieving emissions reduction targets. On the merits, however, the court found that the assessment’s shortcomings did not render it equivalent to a failure to conduct an assessment and that the approval involved no unlawful balancing of interests, ultimately rejecting both claims. The plaintiffs appealed to the Seoul High Court on January 30, 2026.
Complaint
Greenhouse gasFossil fuelGasEnergy supply mitigation+ 37 more

Summary

This is an administrative lawsuit brought by residents and climate advocacy groups against the Minister of Land, Infrastructure and Transport seeking to nullify or cancel the approval of the “Yongin Advanced System Semiconductor Cluster National Industrial Complex Plan” The plaintiffs argue that the project will substantially increase greenhouse gas emissions, exacerbate climate change, and infringe their constitutional and statutory rights to a safe and healthy environment. They rely on the Framework Act on Carbon Neutrality and Green Growth and environmental statutes, asserting that monetary compensation cannot remedy the irreversible harms of climate change.

The plaintiffs contend that the project’s approval relied on deficient environmental and climate impact assessments that failed to account for the full lifecycle emissions of the industrial complex, including electricity demand and hydrogen co-firing limitations. They argue that the development breaches Korea’s national carbon reduction obligations, undermines the 1.5°C climate target, and ignores low-carbon alternatives such as stricter energy efficiency measures and renewable integration. They further assert that approving the project sets a precedent that weakens regulatory oversight and ESG commitments in industrial planning.

The plaintiffs emphasize the broader consequences of the project’s emissions, estimating that it would add several million tons of CO₂ to national outputs, threatening local communities, future generations, and Korea’s climate commitments.

On January 15, 2026, the Seoul Administrative Court recognized the plaintiffs’ standing to challenge the approval of the Yongin semiconductor cluster but dismissed their claims for a declaration of invalidity or, alternatively, cancellation of the approval.

The significance of this holding lies in its recognition of a statutory basis for standing for residents outside the environmental impact assessment area, without requiring specific allegations or proof of environmental harm exceeding tolerable limits, in light of the widespread and unequal impacts of the climate crisis. The court interpreted the Framework Act on Carbon Neutrality and Green Growth as directly and specifically protecting individual citizens’ interests in climate action, including a legally protected interest in using administrative litigation to scrutinize whether climate response plans of national and subnational governments are properly implemented at the climate change impact assessment stage of development approvals. Its reasoning drew on the climate crisis’s widespread and unequal impacts, the Act’s guarantees of procedural participation and access to information, and the role of climate change impact assessments in achieving emissions reduction targets.

On the merits, however, the court found that the assessment’s shortcomings did not render it equivalent to a failure to conduct an assessment and that the approval involved no unlawful balancing of interests, ultimately rejecting both claims. The plaintiffs appealed to the Seoul High Court on January 30, 2026.

 Topics mentioned most in this case

See how often Topics get mentioned in this case and view specific passages of text highlighted in each document.

Group
Topics
Target
Policy instrument
Risk
Impacted group
Just transition
Renewable energy
Fossil fuel
Greenhouse gas
Economic sector
Adaptation/resilience
Finance