In September 2009, the São Paulo State Prosecutor’s Office (MPSP) filed a Public Civil Action (CPA) against Usina Mandu S.A. due to the burning of sugarcane straw during a restricted period.
The first instance decision ordered the defendant to compensate for the environmental damage caused by the illegal burning in the amount of R$400,000.00. Both the plaintiff and the defendant appealed the decision. The MPSP sought an increase in the compensation amount, arguing that the burning had degraded air quality, with negative effects on public health and the environment.
In February 2014, after the MPSP filed a motion for the review of the second instance ruling, the dissenting vote in the appellate judgment prevailed. This dissenting vote held that the polluting company should receive an administrative fine and compensate for the damage caused by the illicit burning. In assessing civil liability, it considered the volume of gases released into the atmosphere, determining this by multiplying the area by the duration of the burn. It estimated emissions of 15 tons of CO₂ per hectare over 30 to 60 minutes, which it regarded as the average burn duration. It ruled that the carbon price should be assessed on the carbon market, as provided on São Paulo’s BM&F BOVESPA. The amount was to be determined in an assessment during the liquidation phase.
In the liquidation phase, the calculated amount was approved, resulting in a final award of compensation of R$215,655.50.
- Climate Litigation Database
- /
- Search
- /
- Brazil
- /
- MPSP vs. Usina Mandu S.A. (Burning of sugarcane straw)
MPSP vs. Usina Mandu S.A. (Burning of sugarcane straw)
About this case
Filing year
2009
Status
Decided
Geography
🇧🇷 Brazil
Court/admin entity
Brazil → Sao Paulo → Sao Paulo State Court
Case category
Suits against corporations, individuals (Global) → Corporations (Global) → Climate damage (Global)
Principal law
Brazil → Federal Constitution of 1988Brazil → National Environmental Policy Act (Law No. 6.938 of 1981)
Topics
, ,
Documents
Each case in our database can contain one or more documents.
Filing Date
Document
Type
Topics
02/24/2021
In September 2009, the São Paulo State Prosecutor’s Office (MPSP) filed a Public Civil Action (CPA) against Usina Mandu S.A. due to the burning of sugarcane straw during a restricted period.
The first instance decision ordered the defendant to compensate for the environmental damage caused by the illegal burning in the amount of R$400,000.00. Both the plaintiff and the defendant appealed the decision. The MPSP sought an increase in the compensation amount, arguing that the burning had degraded air quality, with negative effects on public health and the environment.
In February 2014, after the MPSP filed a motion for the review of the second instance ruling, the dissenting vote in the appellate judgment prevailed. This dissenting vote held that the polluting company should receive an administrative fine and compensate for the damage caused by the illicit burning. In assessing civil liability, it considered the volume of gases released into the atmosphere, determining this by multiplying the area by the duration of the burn. It estimated emissions of 15 tons of CO₂ per hectare over 30 to 60 minutes, which it regarded as the average burn duration. It ruled that the carbon price should be assessed on the carbon market, as provided on São Paulo’s BM&F BOVESPA. The amount was to be determined in an assessment during the liquidation phase.
In the liquidation phase, the calculated amount was approved, resulting in a final award of compensation of R$215,655.50.
Decision
Greenhouse gasCarbon dioxidePublic sectorFinance flow+ 1 more
02/13/2014
Decision (Portuguese)
Decision
Adaptation/resilienceTerrestrial adaptationExtreme weatherTerrestrial risk+ 12 more
08/03/2013
Appellate Decision (Portuguese)
Decision
Finance flowGreenhouse gasCarbon dioxideTerrestrial risk+ 2 more
Summary
Topics mentioned most in this case
See how often Topics get mentioned in this case and view specific passages of text highlighted in each document.
Group
Topics
Policy instrument
Risk
Impacted group
Renewable energy
Greenhouse gas
Economic sector
Adaptation/resilience
Finance