Skip to content
The Climate Litigation Database

PPC Power v Slovak Financial Directorate

Geography
International
Year
2017
Document Type
Litigation

About this case

Filing year
2017
Status
Decided
Geography
International
Court/admin entity
European Union → European Court of Justice
Case category
Suits against governments (Global) → GHG emissions reduction and trading (Global) → EU ETS (Global)
Principal law
European Union → Secondary Law → Directives → 2003/87/EC
Topics
, ,  

Documents

Each case in our database can contain one or more documents.

Filing Date
Document
Type
Topics
04/12/2018
PPC Power operates an installation in Slovakia that is subject to the European Union Emissions Trading System (EU ETS). In addition to the EU ETS requirements, the government of Slovakia imposed an 80% tax on emission allowances that were transferred or unused and therefore allocated free of charge. This tax was applied between January 1, 2011 and June 30, 2012. During this period, two advance payments were due and were calculated based on the estimated tax amount. PPC Power requested that the Tax Administration for Certain Taxpayers, Slovakia (the DU), set the amount of the advance tax payable for 2011 at zero because the legislation establishing the 80% tax rate was inconsistent with Directive 2003/87/EC. The DU rejected PPC Power's request and set the advance payment for the first half of 2011 at EUR 300,000, which PPC Power paid and subsequently paid to recover. The DU refused repayment, and the Directorate of Tax Administration of the Slovak Republic dismissed PPC Power’s appeal. PPC Power then paid EUR 300,000 for the second half of 2011, as set by the DU. After the DU ultimately rejected that application, PPC Power filed suit with the Regional Court of Bratislava, contesting, on the one hand, the decision of the Slovak Republic tax administration rejecting its application for repayment of the advance tax payment for the first half of 2011 and, on the other, the DU’s decision, setting the amount of advance tax due for the second half of 2011. The Regional Court referred the following question to the European Court of Justice (ECJ): whether Directive 2003/87 must be interpreted as precluding national tax legislation, such as that at issue in the main proceedings. The ECJ ruled that Directive 2003/87/EC "must be interpreted as precluding national legislation, such as that at issue in the main proceedings, which taxes, at 80% of their value, greenhouse gas emission allowances allocated free of charge that have been sold or not used by undertakings subject to the greenhouse gas emission trading scheme." The ECJ acknowledged that Directive 2003/87/EC requires Member States to allocate at least 90% of emission allowances free of charge but still allows member states to determine procedures for allocating them. However, the ECJ found that the Slovakian tax eliminated "virtually all of the economic value of emission allowances," and therefore negated the incentive mechanisms underpinning the EU ETS. To reduce emissions in the manner prescribed by the EU ETS, the ECJ ruled that Directive 2003/87/EC must be interpreted as precluding national legislation such as that at issue in Slovakia.
Decision
Tradable permitTaxGreenhouse gasFinance flow+ 3 more
05/24/2017
Other
Tradable permitTaxGreenhouse gasFinance and insurance sector

Summary

PPC Power operates an installation in Slovakia that is subject to the European Union Emissions Trading System (EU ETS). In addition to the EU ETS requirements, the government of Slovakia imposed an 80% tax on emission allowances that were transferred or unused and therefore allocated free of charge. This tax was applied between January 1, 2011 and June 30, 2012. During this period, two advance payments were due and were calculated based on the estimated tax amount.

PPC Power requested that the Tax Administration for Certain Taxpayers, Slovakia (the DU), set the amount of the advance tax payable for 2011 at zero because the legislation establishing the 80% tax rate was inconsistent with Directive 2003/87/EC. The DU rejected PPC Power's request and set the advance payment for the first half of 2011 at EUR 300,000, which PPC Power paid and subsequently paid to recover. The DU refused repayment, and the Directorate of Tax Administration of the Slovak Republic dismissed PPC Power’s appeal. PPC Power then paid EUR 300,000 for the second half of 2011, as set by the DU.

After the DU ultimately rejected that application, PPC Power filed suit with the Regional Court of Bratislava, contesting, on the one hand, the decision of the Slovak Republic tax administration rejecting its application for repayment of the advance tax payment for the first half of 2011 and, on the other, the DU’s decision, setting the amount of advance tax due for the second half of 2011. The Regional Court referred the following question to the European Court of Justice (ECJ): whether Directive 2003/87 must be interpreted as precluding national tax legislation, such as that at issue in the main proceedings.

The ECJ ruled that Directive 2003/87/EC "must be interpreted as precluding national legislation, such as that at issue in the main proceedings, which taxes, at 80% of their value, greenhouse gas emission allowances allocated free of charge that have been sold or not used by undertakings subject to the greenhouse gas emission trading scheme." The ECJ acknowledged that Directive 2003/87/EC requires Member States to allocate at least 90% of emission allowances free of charge but still allows member states to determine procedures for allocating them. However, the ECJ found that the Slovakian tax eliminated "virtually all of the economic value of emission allowances," and therefore negated the incentive mechanisms underpinning the EU ETS. To reduce emissions in the manner prescribed by the EU ETS, the ECJ ruled that Directive 2003/87/EC must be interpreted as precluding national legislation such as that at issue in Slovakia.

 Topics mentioned most in this case

See how often Topics get mentioned in this case and view specific passages of text highlighted in each document.

Group
Topics
Policy instrument
Greenhouse gas
Economic sector
Finance