Skip to content
The Climate Litigation Database

Public Defender’s Office of the State of Pará vs. RMDLT Property Group and others (Project 997 carbon credits and “forest carbon grabbing”)

Geography
🇧🇷 Brazil → Pará
Year
2023
Document Type
Litigation

About this case

Filing year
2023
Status
Pending
Geography
🇧🇷 Brazil → Pará
Court/admin entity
Brazil → Pará → Pará State Court
Case category
Suits against corporations, individuals (Global) → Corporations (Global) → Carbon credits (Global)Suits against governments (Global) → Environmental assessment and permitting (Global) → Other projects (Global)
Principal law
Brazil → Federal Constitution of 1988Brazil → Forest Code (Law No. 12.651 of 2012)Brazil → ILO Convention 169 concerning Indigenous and Tribal Peoples (enacted by Decree No. 5.051 of 2004, later revoked by Decree No. 10.088 of 2019)Brazil → UN Framework Convention on Climate Change - UNFCCC (enacted by Federal Decree 2652/1998)
Topics
, ,  

Documents

Each case in our database can contain one or more documents.

Filing Date
Document
Type
Topics
07/24/2023
Petition
Marginalized ethnicityOther land use mitigationTerrestrial adaptationAdaptation/resilience+ 27 more

Summary

On July 24, 2023, the Public Defender's Office of the State of Pará (DPE-PA) filed a Public Civil Action (ACP) with a request for injunctive relief against RMDLT Property Group Ltda, Brazil Property Group Compra, Venda e Locação de Imóvel Ltda, Brazil Agfor LLC, Agfor Empreendimentos Ltda, Michael Edward Greene and the municipality of Portel due to a project that generate illegal carbon credits sold on the voluntary market. This ACP is part of a set of four lawsuits filed by the DPE-PA on the same grounds, but challenging different carbon credit projects. The RMDLT Portel-Pará REDD Project or Rio Mandaquari REDD+ Project (Project 977), which is the object of the lawsuit, overlaps areas of the State Agro-Extractivist Settlement Projects (PEAEX) Deus é Fiel and Joana Peres II - Dorothy Stang. These PEAEXs are public lands whose real right of use is granted to traditional communities located in the municipality of Portel, in the state of Pará, which did not participate in the contested project. Project 977 generates REDD+ assets (credits generated by avoided deforestation, sustainable management and increased forest carbon stocks), was certified by an international company and was established in 2009 to generate carbon credits for forty years. Companies and individuals are sued for being responsible, developers of the project or alleged owners of the rural properties where it is located. The DPE-PA alleges irregularities in the property registrations that make up the enterprise, and that the project does not have authorisation from the state of Pará, which characterises the grabbing of public land. In addition, the mayor of Portel issued a Public Utility Decree authorising its operation, which the DPE-PA argues is unconstitutional. It is emphasised that the project was implemented without a prior technical study. The DPE-PA argues that the defendants acted in violation of the right to traditional territory, the right to prior, free and informed consultation of traditional communities, that they did not comply with federal legislation on climate change, payments for environmental services and public forest concessions and did not benefit the communities directly affected by the project. The plaintiff argues that the defendants' behaviour entails the duty to compensate for collective moral damage. As an injunction, the plaintiff requests (i) recognition of the possession of the lands by the traditional communities; (ii) suspension of Project 997 and an order that the defendants refrain from entering the PEAEX. On the merits, the plaintiff requests (i) confirmation of the requests for an injunction; (ii) recognition of the right to the traditional territory; (iii) the annulment of Project 977 and the legal transactions derived from it; (iv) an order to prohibit the defendants from entering the territories; (v) a declaration that the Public Utility Decree issued by the Municipality of Portel is null and void; (vi) an order to pay collective moral damages in the amount of R$ 5,000,000.00 to be paid into the Eastern Amazon Fund in favour of the communities of the extractivist territories of Portel.

The court granted the request to include the Pará Land Institute (ITERPA) as a plaintiff in the lawsuit.

Brazil Property Group Compra, Venda e Locação de Imóveis LTDA, AGFOR Empreendimentos LTDA, and Brazil AGFOR filed identical defenses, given that Michael Greene is a partner in all three legal entities, alleging preliminarily: (i) lack of standing of the Public Defender's Office of Pará (DPE-PA) due to the absence of a power of attorney to represent the communities; (ii) lack of standing, since they would not be responsible for land issues concerning the areas of Project 981; and (iii) inadequacy of the initial pleading, due to the lack of demonstration of a causal link between the defendant's conduct and the alleged damages, especially regarding the request for compensation for collective moral damages. On the merits, they argued, among other points, that the lands of Project 981 were not subject to land grabbing, indicating that, contrary to what the DPE-PA alleges, the community areas unduly overlapped private properties. They highlighted that the improper inclusion of riparian areas in the project was the result of errors by the original developers and that, upon assuming management, Michael Greene, aware of the situation, formally requested the Verra certification company to exclude these areas, promoting the necessary corrections and aligning the project with applicable regulations. They argued that there is no causal link, unlawful act, or attributable liability to the parties, since the lands involved legitimately belong to individuals; (ii) the initial irregularities were caused by previous developers and corrected during Michael Greene's management; and (iii) no carbon credits were generated during the petitioners' administration.The only mention of the climate issue was limited to the potential role of carbon credit projects in reducing deforestation, mitigating the main cause of greenhouse gas emissions in Brazil. Finally, they request (i) their exclusion from the passive pole; (ii) the total dismissal of the merits of the action; (iii) the challenge to the value of the case; and (iv) the carrying out of an expert examination of documents relating to the properties discussed in the action.

 Topics mentioned most in this case

See how often Topics get mentioned in this case and view specific passages of text highlighted in each document.

Group
Topics
Policy instrument
Risk
Impacted group
Fossil fuel
Greenhouse gas
Economic sector
Adaptation/resilience
Finance