Professor Andrew Weaver, a renowned Canadian climate scientist, filed suit against the National Post, its publisher, and several journalists for defamation. Dr. Weaver’s claims arose out of the defendants’ publication of statements that allegedly injured Dr. Weaver’s reputation as a climate scientist in the context of the “Climategate” controversy. Plaintiff Weaver sought an injunction requiring the newspaper to remove the allegedly false statements from its website and from any sites where the statements were reposted. The Supreme Court of British Columbia found that the defendants had defamed Dr. Weaver and that their statements were not protected by the defense of fair comment because the facts upon which they relied were false. The Court awarded Dr. Weaver $50,000 in general damages, and directed the defendants to remove the offending articles, require third parties to cease republication, and publish a retraction.
The defendants appealed before the Court of Appeal for British Columbia and argued that the judge had erred in finding them jointly liable for defamation. They notably argued that the judge had erred in analyzing whether the articles were defamatory in combination and in imposing joint liability. With the exception of one article, there was no evidence of collaboration or referability. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal on that basis, and ordered a new trial for the necessary analysis to be undertaken and findings of fact to be made.
- Climate Litigation Database
- /
- Search
- /
- Canada
- /
- Weaver v. Corcoran and Others
Weaver v. Corcoran and Others
About this case
Filing year
2010
Status
Decided
Geography
🇨🇦 Canada → British Columbia
Court/admin entity
Canada → British Columbia → Court of Appeal → Supreme Court
Case category
Suits against corporations, individuals (Global) → Corporations (Global)
Principal law
CanadaLibel
Topics
, ,
Documents
Each case in our database can contain one or more documents.
Filing Date
Document
Type
Topics
04/21/2017
Professor Andrew Weaver, a renowned Canadian climate scientist, filed suit against the National Post, its publisher, and several journalists for defamation. Dr. Weaver’s claims arose out of the defendants’ publication of statements that allegedly injured Dr. Weaver’s reputation as a climate scientist in the context of the “Climategate” controversy. Plaintiff Weaver sought an injunction requiring the newspaper to remove the allegedly false statements from its website and from any sites where the statements were reposted. The Supreme Court of British Columbia found that the defendants had defamed Dr. Weaver and that their statements were not protected by the defense of fair comment because the facts upon which they relied were false. The Court awarded Dr. Weaver $50,000 in general damages, and directed the defendants to remove the offending articles, require third parties to cease republication, and publish a retraction.
The defendants appealed before the Court of Appeal for British Columbia and argued that the judge had erred in finding them jointly liable for defamation. They notably argued that the judge had erred in analyzing whether the articles were defamatory in combination and in imposing joint liability. With the exception of one article, there was no evidence of collaboration or referability. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal on that basis, and ordered a new trial for the necessary analysis to be undertaken and findings of fact to be made.
Decision
Fossil fuelSlow onset eventOilMedia sector+ 7 more
02/05/2015
Professor Andrew Weaver, a renowned Canadian climate scientist, filed suit against the National Post, its publisher, and several journalists for defamation. Dr. Weaver’s claims arose out of the defendants’ publication of statements that allegedly injured Dr. Weaver’s reputation as a climate scientist in the context of the “Climategate” controversy. Plaintiff Weaver sought an injunction requiring the newspaper to remove the allegedly false statements from its website and from any sites where the statements were reposted. The Supreme Court of British Columbia found that the defendants had defamed Dr. Weaver and that their statements were not protected by the defense of fair comment because the facts upon which they relied were false. The Court awarded Dr. Weaver $50,000 in general damages, and directed the defendants to remove the offending articles, require third parties to cease republication, and publish a retraction.
The defendants appealed before the Court of Appeal for British Columbia and argued that the judge had erred in finding them jointly liable for defamation. They notably argued that the judge had erred in analyzing whether the articles were defamatory in combination and in imposing joint liability. With the exception of one article, there was no evidence of collaboration or referability. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal on that basis, and ordered a new trial for the necessary analysis to be undertaken and findings of fact to be made.
Decision
Slow onset eventFossil fuelOilMedia sector+ 22 more
02/12/2012
Professor Andrew Weaver, a renowned Canadian climate scientist, filed suit against the National Post, its publisher, and several journalists for defamation. Dr. Weaver’s claims arose out of the defendants’ publication of statements that allegedly injured Dr. Weaver’s reputation as a climate scientist in the context of the “Climategate” controversy. Plaintiff Weaver sought an injunction requiring the newspaper to remove the allegedly false statements from its website and from any sites where the statements were reposted. The Supreme Court of British Columbia found that the defendants had defamed Dr. Weaver and that their statements were not protected by the defense of fair comment because the facts upon which they relied were false. The Court awarded Dr. Weaver $50,000 in general damages, and directed the defendants to remove the offending articles, require third parties to cease republication, and publish a retraction.
The defendants appealed before the Court of Appeal for British Columbia and argued that the judge had erred in finding them jointly liable for defamation. They notably argued that the judge had erred in analyzing whether the articles were defamatory in combination and in imposing joint liability. With the exception of one article, there was no evidence of collaboration or referability. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal on that basis, and ordered a new trial for the necessary analysis to be undertaken and findings of fact to be made.
Decision
Fossil fuelSlow onset eventOilMedia sector+ 22 more
Summary
Topics mentioned most in this case
See how often Topics get mentioned in this case and view specific passages of text highlighted in each document.
Group
Topics
Policy instrument
Risk
Impacted group
Just transition
Fossil fuel
Greenhouse gas
Economic sector
Adaptation/resilience
Finance