Skip to content
The Climate Litigation Database

Kunaknana v. United States Army Corps of Engineers

Kunaknana v. United States Army Corps of Engineers ↗

3:13-cv-00044United States District Court for the District of Alaska (D. Alaska)10 entries
Filing Date
Document
Type
05/04/2016
Settlement reached and fees petition withdrawn.
On May 4, 2016, the plaintiffs in a lawsuit that succeeded in requiring the United States Army Corps on Engineers to conduct supplemental environmental analysis for a wetlands fill permit in the National Petroleum Reserve withdrew their petition for attorneys’ fees and other costs under the Equal Access to Justice Act. The plaintiffs said that reached an agreement with the federal defendants that settled their request for fees and costs.
Motion
08/27/2015
Petition for costs and fees submitted by plaintiff.
Plaintiffs who challenged issuance of a fill permit for a drill site in the National Petroleum Reserve in Alaska filed a petition for costs and fees under the federal Equal Access to Justice Act (EAJA). The federal district court for the District of Alaska upheld the permit in 2015, but only after it first remanded the proceeding to the United States Army Corps of Engineers (Corps) in 2014 for a reasoned explanation for the Corps’ decision not to conduct a supplemental environmental analysis. The supplemental analysis subsequently conducted by the Corps included a discussion of whether new information about climate change warranted preparation of a supplemental environmental impact statement and concluded that it did not. In their fees petition, the plaintiffs contended that they were prevailing parties for purposes of EAJA because the court was only satisfied that the Corps had satisfied its NEPA obligations after the Corps completed the supplemental analysis required by the court.
Petition
05/26/2015
Second order re motions for summary judgment issued.
The federal district court for the District of Alaska upheld the approval by the United States Army Corps of Engineers (Corps) of a permit to fill wetlands in the National Petroleum Reserve in Alaska for development of a drilling site. The Corps prepared a supplemental information report (SIR) after the court held in 2014 that the Corps had not provided a reasoned explanation for its decision not to prepare a supplemental environmental impact statement (SEIS) to update a 2004 EIS. Pursuant to an agreement between the parties and an order of the court, the SIR included a discussion of whether new information about climate change necessitated preparation of an SEIS. The Corps considered both the impact of climate change on the project and the project’s impacts on climate change. The court agreed with plaintiffs that the Corps had conducted “only a minimalist review” of the impacts of climate change. Nevertheless, the court found that this assessment was adequate given the absence of detailed instructions from the court regarding the analysis the Corps should have performed and given that the plaintiffs had not identified specific climate change information the Corps should have considered. The court also found that the Corps’ determinations that other new information and changes to the project did not require an SEIS were not arbitrary and capricious, and that the Corps had an adequate basis for its determination that the project was the Least Environmentally Damaging Practicable Alternative as required under Section 404 of the Clean Water Act. Judgment was entered for the defendants on May 29, 2015.
Decision
07/22/2014
Order re further proceedings issued.
In July, the court issued an order regarding further proceedings in the case. The court opted not to vacate the permit because stopping ongoing construction would have disruptive consequences. On remand, the court directed the Corps to consider post-2004 information on how climate change could affect the project. The court denied the challengers’ request for a public hearing, noting that the National Environmental Policy Act did not require a public hearing for a determination of whether to prepare a supplemental environmental impact statement. The Corps was required to submit its determination on remand by August 27.
Decision