Skip to content
The Climate Litigation Database

Maniototo Environmental Society Inc. v. Central Otago District Council; Meridian Energy Ltd. v. Central Otago District Council and Others

Geography
🇳🇿 New Zealand
Year
2008
Document Type
Litigation

About this case

Filing year
2008
Status
Remanded to Environment Court
Geography
🇳🇿 New Zealand
Court/admin entity
New Zealand → Environment CourtNew Zealand → High Court of New Zealand
Case category
Suits against governments (Global)
Principal law
New Zealand → Resource Management Act 1991
Topics
, ,  

Documents

Each case in our database can contain one or more documents.

Filing Date
Document
Type
Topics
08/16/2010
Applicants challenged the granting of resource consents to Meridian Energy for the construction of a wind farm using up to 176 wind turbines. The Environment Court of New Zealand conducted a cost-benefit analysis of the proposed wind farm and determined that the project did not comply with the Resource Management Act because the substantial adverse impacts on the natural landscape outweighed the positive factors, principally the large quantity of renewable energy. Meridian appealed the decision challenging the court’s use of cost-benefit analysis and consideration of alternative sites. The High Court of New Zealand allowed the appeal and remanded the case back to the Environment Court. While the High Court found that the Environment Court was permitted to use cost benefit analysis, it instructed the court to allow Meridian to give further information on alternatives and opportunity to present a market-based analysis of impacts. In addition, the High Court denied a cross-appeal alleging the court had erred in considering climate change impacts without first determining the extent to which climate change is caused by human activity. Before the Environment Court revisited the issue, Meridian announced that it had withdrawn its applications for resource consent.
Decision
Energy supply mitigationRenewable energyEnergy supply sectorHospitality sector+ 20 more
11/06/2009
Applicants challenged the granting of resource consents to Meridian Energy for the construction of a wind farm using up to 176 wind turbines. The Environment Court of New Zealand conducted a cost-benefit analysis of the proposed wind farm and determined that the project did not comply with the Resource Management Act because the substantial adverse impacts on the natural landscape outweighed the positive factors, principally the large quantity of renewable energy. Meridian appealed the decision challenging the court’s use of cost-benefit analysis and consideration of alternative sites. The High Court of New Zealand allowed the appeal and remanded the case back to the Environment Court. While the High Court found that the Environment Court was permitted to use cost benefit analysis, it instructed the court to allow Meridian to give further information on alternatives and opportunity to present a market-based analysis of impacts. In addition, the High Court denied a cross-appeal alleging the court had erred in considering climate change impacts without first determining the extent to which climate change is caused by human activity. Before the Environment Court revisited the issue, Meridian announced that it had withdrawn its applications for resource consent.
Decision
Energy supply mitigationRenewable energyConstruction sectorAdaptation/resilience+ 52 more

Summary

Applicants challenged the granting of resource consents to Meridian Energy for the construction of a wind farm using up to 176 wind turbines. The Environment Court of New Zealand conducted a cost-benefit analysis of the proposed wind farm and determined that the project did not comply with the Resource Management Act because the substantial adverse impacts on the natural landscape outweighed the positive factors, principally the large quantity of renewable energy.

Meridian appealed the decision challenging the court’s use of cost-benefit analysis and consideration of alternative sites. The High Court of New Zealand allowed the appeal and remanded the case back to the Environment Court. While the High Court found that the Environment Court was permitted to use cost benefit analysis, it instructed the court to allow Meridian to give further information on alternatives and opportunity to present a market-based analysis of impacts. In addition, the High Court denied a cross-appeal alleging the court had erred in considering climate change impacts without first determining the extent to which climate change is caused by human activity.

Before the Environment Court revisited the issue, Meridian announced that it had withdrawn its applications for resource consent.

 Topics mentioned most in this case

See how often Topics get mentioned in this case and view specific passages of text highlighted in each document.

Group
Topics
Target
Policy instrument
Risk
Impacted group
Just transition
Renewable energy
Fossil fuel
Greenhouse gas
Economic sector
Adaptation/resilience
Finance