Skip to content
The Climate Litigation Database

Ohio v. EPA

Geography
Year
2022
Document Type
Litigation
Part of

About this case

Filing year
2022
Status
Motion for abeyance filed by EPA.
Docket number
22-1081
Court/admin entity
United States → United States Federal Courts → United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia (D.C. Cir.)
Case category
Federal Statutory Claims (US) → Clean Air Act (US) → Industry Lawsuits (US) → State and Municipal Vehicle Standards (US)
Principal law
United States → Clean Air Act (CAA)
At issue
Challenge to EPA's reinstatement of the waiver allowing California to regulate greenhouse gas emissions from motor vehicles.
Topics
, ,  

Documents

Each case in our database can contain one or more documents.

Filing Date
Document
Type
Topics
12/05/2025
Motion for abeyance filed by EPA.
Motion
Transportation and logistics sectorPublic sector
04/09/2024
Petitions for review denied.
The D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals denied petitions for review challenging the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA’s) 2022 reinstatement of the 2013 waiver under the Clean Air Act of federal preemption for California’s Advanced Clean Car Program regulations. The California regulations included greenhouse gas emissions requirements for automobiles for Model Years 2017 to 2025 and a requirement that around 15% of manufacturers’ fleets be zero-emissions vehicles by Model Year 2025. The D.C. Circuit found that neither state petitioners nor fuel petitioners (entities and trade associations involved in the production or sale of liquid fuels) had standing for statutory claims because they failed to allege that a favorable decision would redress their alleged economic injuries. The court said there was no basis to conclude that third-party automobile manufacturers “would, in fact, change course with respect to the relevant model years” if the court vacated the waiver. The D.C. Circuit therefore did not consider the merits of the fuel petitioners’ argument that California’s regulations did not meet the Clean Air Act’s criteria for a waiver of preemption or the merits of the state petitioners’ argument that the waiver was contrary to the Energy Policy and Conservation Act’s preemption of state fuel economy standards. The D.C. Circuit found that the state petitioners did have standing for their constitutional claim that the waiver provision of the Clean Air Act violated the “equal sovereignty principle.” The court, however, rejected this claim on the merits, concluding that the principle did not extend to laws enacted under Congress’s Commerce Clause power.
Decision
Codes and standardsGreenhouse gasTransportation and logistics sectorFossil fuel+ 27 more
08/18/2023
Order issued regarding format for oral argument.
The D.C. Circuit issued an order regarding the format of September 15, 2023 oral arguments in challenges to EPA’s reinstatement of the waiver allowing California to regulate greenhouse gas emissions from motor vehicles. The order specified that oral arguments would feature counsel for private petitioners, state petitioners, EPA, and California and focus on standing and zone of interests, Clean Air Act authority and reconsideration authority, equal sovereignty, and Energy Policy and Conservation Act issues.
Decision
Youth
08/09/2023
Petitioner states' motion for leave to supplement the record denied.
Decision
05/26/2023
Letter filed by respondent-intervenor California in response to petitioner Ohio's letter regarding supplemental authority (National Pork Producers Council v. Ross).
Letter
Codes and standardsManufacturing sector
05/23/2023
Letter filed by EPA in response to Ohio petitioner's supplemental authority (National Pork Producers Council v. Ross).
Letter
05/16/2023
Letter filed by petitioner Ohio regarding supplemental authority (National Pork Producers Council v. Ross).
Letter
Codes and standards
05/01/2023
Letter filed by California in response to petitioner Ohio's supplemental authority (California Restaurant Association v. City of Berkeley).
Letter
Codes and standardsBanGreenhouse gasFossil fuel+ 1 more
05/01/2023
Letter filed by EPA in response to petitioner Ohio's supplemental authority (California Restaurant Association v. City of Berkeley).
Letter
Codes and standards
04/24/2023
Letter filed by petitioner Ohio regarding supplemental authority (California Restaurant Association v. City of Berkeley).
Letter
Fossil fuelGasBanTransportation and logistics sector
03/27/2023
Reply filed by petitioner states in support of motion for leave to supplement the record.
Reply
ElectrificationGreenhouse gasGas
03/20/2023
Opposition filed by EPA to state petitioners' motion for leave to supplement the record.
Opposition
BanGreenhouse gasTransportation and logistics sectorFinance and insurance sector
03/20/2023
Opposition filed by state and local government respondent-intervenors to state petitioners' motion for leave to supplement the record.
Opposition
TaxTransportation and logistics sectorCodes and standardsElectrification+ 2 more
03/10/2023
Reply brief filed by petitioner states.
Reply
Codes and standardsTransportation and logistics sectorElectrificationSubsidy+ 8 more
03/10/2023
Motion filed by state petitioners for leave to supplement the record.
Motion
Transportation and logistics sectorSubsidyFinance flowCodes and standards+ 2 more
03/10/2023
Reply brief filed by private petitioners.
Reply
Greenhouse gasCodes and standardsGasElectrification+ 9 more
02/13/2023
Brief filed by state and local government respondent-intervenors.
Brief
Codes and standardsGreenhouse gasAir pollution riskTransportation and logistics sector+ 21 more
02/13/2023
Brief filed by industry respondent-intervenors.
Brief
ElectrificationGasGreenhouse gasTransportation and logistics sector+ 27 more
02/13/2023
Brief filed by respondent-intervenor public interest organizations.
Brief
Greenhouse gasFossil fuelGasAir pollution risk+ 6 more
01/20/2023
Brief filed by administrative law professors as amici curiae in support of respondents.
Amicus Motion/Brief
Codes and standardsAir pollution riskEducation sectorBan+ 5 more
01/20/2023
Brief filed by amici curiae Senator Tom Carper and Representative Frank Pallone, Jr. in support of respondents.
Amicus Motion/Brief
Codes and standardsGreenhouse gasFossil fuelOil+ 26 more
01/20/2023
Brief filed by Professor Leah M. Litman as amicus curiae in support of respondents.
Amicus Motion/Brief
BanTrade sectorAgriculture sectorCodes and standards+ 10 more
01/20/2023
Brief filed by public health professional groups on behalf of respondents.
Amicus Motion/Brief
Air pollution riskExtreme weatherGreenhouse gasTransportation and logistics sector+ 21 more
01/20/2023
Brief filed by amicus curiae South Coast Air Quality Management District in support of respondents.
Amicus Motion/Brief
Air pollution riskGreenhouse gasCodes and standardsTransportation and logistics sector+ 2 more
01/18/2023
Brief filed by amici curiae California climate scientists in support of respondents.
Amicus Motion/Brief
Extreme weatherTerrestrial riskGreenhouse gasAir pollution risk+ 40 more
01/13/2023
Brief filed by respondents.
Brief
Greenhouse gasCodes and standardsTransportation and logistics sectorCarbon dioxide+ 60 more
11/08/2022
Brief filed by Conserv America as amicus curiae in support of petitioners and remand to the agency.
Amicus Motion/Brief
ElectrificationGreenhouse gasFossil fuelOil+ 13 more
11/07/2022
Brief file by Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association, Inc. as amicus curiae in support of petitioners.
Amicus Motion/Brief
ElectrificationTransportation and logistics sectorFossil fuelOil+ 17 more
11/07/2022
Brief filed by amicus curiae the Sulphur Institute in support of petitioners State of Ohio et al.
Amicus Motion/Brief
Fossil fuelChemical impactEnergy storageElectrification+ 26 more
11/03/2022
Brief filed by amicus curiae the Two Hundred for Housing Equity.
Amicus Motion/Brief
ElectrificationPeople with limited assetsFossil fuelTransportation and logistics sector+ 24 more
11/03/2022
Brief filed by amici curiae Texas Oil & Gas Association et al. in support of petitioners.
Amicus Motion/Brief
Fossil fuelOilGasEnergy supply sector+ 18 more
11/02/2022
Brief filed by state petitioners.
Brief
Codes and standardsGreenhouse gasTransportation and logistics sectorCarbon dioxide+ 18 more
10/31/2022
Brief filed by amici curiae Western States Petroleum Association et al. in support of petitioners.
Amicus Motion/Brief
Fossil fuelOilElectrificationTransportation and logistics sector+ 22 more
10/31/2022
Brief of amici curiae American Commitment et al. filed in support of petitioners.
Amicus Motion/Brief
TaxGreenhouse gasWomen and minority gendersTransportation and logistics sector+ 15 more
10/31/2022
Brief filed by amici curiae California Business Roundtable & California Manufacturers & Technology Association in support of petitioners.
Amicus Motion/Brief
Energy storageElectrificationExtractive sectorManufacturing sector+ 24 more
10/27/2022
Brief filed by amicus curiae Western States Trucking Association, Inc. in support of petitioners.
Amicus Motion/Brief
Codes and standardsConstruction sectorBanTransportation and logistics sector+ 8 more
10/24/2022
Brief filed by private petitioners.
Brief
Greenhouse gasCodes and standardsGasEnergy supply mitigation+ 21 more
06/13/2022
Motion for leave to intervene in support of respondents filed by Advanced Energy Economy et al.
Motion To Intervene
ElectrificationGreenhouse gasTransportation and logistics sectorCodes and standards+ 22 more
06/13/2022
Motion to intervene as respondent filed by National Coalition for Advanced Transportation.
Motion To Intervene
Transportation and logistics sectorElectrificationCodes and standardsFossil fuel+ 10 more
06/07/2022
Motion to intervene in support of respondents filed by Ford Motor Company et al.
Motion To Intervene
ElectrificationGreenhouse gasCodes and standardsEnergy supply mitigation+ 8 more
05/19/2022
Motion for leave to intervene in support of respondents filed by California, 19 other states, the District of Columbia, Los Angeles, and New York City.
Motion To Intervene
Codes and standardsGreenhouse gasAir pollution riskEnergy supply mitigation+ 7 more
05/12/2022
Motion to intervene in support of respondents filed by public interest organizations.
Motion To Intervene
Greenhouse gasExtreme weatherAir pollution riskCodes and standards+ 18 more
05/12/2022
Petition for review filed.
Four petitions for review were filed in the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals challenging EPA’s action reinstating the waiver allowing California to regulate greenhouse gas emissions from motor vehicles. The petitions were filed by (1) 17 states led by Ohio; (2) the Soybean Associations for the States of Iowa, Minnesota, and South Dakota, and Diamond Alternative Energy, LLC, a subsidiary of Valero Energy Corporation; (3) American Fuel & Petrochemical Manufacturers, Domestic Energy Producers Alliance, Energy Marketers of America, and National Association of Convenience Stores; and (4) Clean Fuels Development Coalition and six other petitioners that described themselves as “part of the renewable fuel industry and … specifically focused on the production and sale of corn ethanol.” Twenty states, the District of Columbia, Los Angeles, and New York City moved to intervene in support of EPA, as did 10 nongovernmental organizations that identified themselves as “public interest organizations.”
Petition
Greenhouse gasCodes and standardsTransportation and logistics sectorExtreme weather+ 15 more

Summary

Challenge to EPA's reinstatement of the waiver allowing California to regulate greenhouse gas emissions from motor vehicles.

 Topics mentioned most in this case

See how often Topics get mentioned in this case and view specific passages of text highlighted in each document.

Group
Topics
Target
Policy instrument
Risk
Impacted group
Just transition
Renewable energy
Fossil fuel
Greenhouse gas
Economic sector
Adaptation/resilience
Finance