In June 2021, Eastleigh Borough Council granted planning permission for the expansion of Southampton Airport, including through the extension of an existing runway. That decision was challenged on public law grounds by GOESA Ltd, with “GOESA” standing for the Group Opposed to the Expansion of Southampton Airport.
The proposed length of extension of the runway would be 164 meters. In addition to the extension, planning permission was sought for an associated blast screen and the reconfiguration and enlargement of the existing long stay car park. Additional grounds by which the claim was brought include: (1) Legitimate expectation (re: Secretary of State call‑in timing); (2) Misinterpretation of NPPF paragraph 11(d) (“tilted balance”); (3) Considering an immaterial consideration (airport closure risk); and (4) Insufficient evidence that the airport would be operating below its break-eve point without expansion. Permission was originally refused in October 2021 but renewed later.
Giving judgment in May 2022, the High Court dismissed the claim.
The council had not breached the Environmental Impact Assessment Regulations. The focus of these regulations was to require the council to reach conclusions on the likely significant effects of the proposal on the environment. No criteria or thresholds had been set by which to measure the “significance” of the GHG emissions from a particular proposal. Nor was the court referred to any guidance for assessing the acceptability of that contribution, whether expressed as a percentage of national budgets or sectoral targets or otherwise.
The EIA Regulations focus on assessing the significance of an environmental effect. The legislation does not deal with the acceptability of an effect identified by environmental information. That is a matter of judgement for the decision-maker, not a hard-edged point of law. On the basis of current policy and law it was permissible for a planning authority to look at the scale of the GHG emissions relative to a national target and to reach a judgement, which may inevitably be of a generalised nature, about the likelihood of the proposal harming the achievement of that target. There was nothing unlawful about the inevitably broad judgement reached in the present case.
Further, the council did lawfully assess the cumulative effects of emissions from the expansion of Southampton Airport together with proposals for developing Bristol, Stansted and Leeds Bradford airports.
In August 2022, the Court of Appeal refused GOESA permission to appeal, bringing the litigation to an end.
- Climate Litigation Database
- /
- Search
- /
- United Kingdom
- /
- R (GOESA Ltd) v Eastleigh Borough Council and Southampton International Airport Ltd
R (GOESA Ltd) v Eastleigh Borough Council and Southampton International Airport Ltd
About this case
Filing year
2021
Status
Decided
Geography
Court/admin entity
United Kingdom → England and Wales → High Court of Justice
Case category
Suits against governments (Global) → Environmental assessment and permitting (Global) → Other projects (Global)
Principal law
United Kingdom → Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (England and Wales)United Kingdom → Town and County Planning (EIA) Regulations 2017
Topics
, ,
Documents
Each case in our database can contain one or more documents.
Filing Date
Document
Type
Topics
08/01/2022
Other
Finance flowConstruction sectorTransportation and logistics sector
05/23/2022
Decision
Greenhouse gasTransportation and logistics sectorTargetEmissions reduction target+ 7 more
Summary
Topics mentioned most in this case
See how often Topics get mentioned in this case and view specific passages of text highlighted in each document.
Group
Topics
Target
Just transition
Greenhouse gas
Economic sector
Finance