This case concerned appeals against resource consents for the expansion of a spring water extraction and water bottling operation run by Ōtākiri Springs Ltd (OSL) near Whakatāne. Among others, Sustainable Ōtākiri Inc (representing local residents) and Te Rūnanga o Ngāti Awa (representing the local iwi) appealed the consents unsuccessfully to the Environment Court, High Court and Court of Appeal.
The case was appealed to the Supreme Court. One of five issues before the Supreme Court was whether the potential environmental effects of end-user disposal of plastic bottles are a relevant ""effect"" under s 104(1)(a) of the Resource Management Act 1991 (RMA). The Supreme Court assessed the ambit of “effect”, including significant obiter discussion of earlier New Zealand case law on greenhouse gas emissions as an effect on the environment, and whether this could include scope 3 emissions.
On November 12, 2025, New Zealand’s Supreme Court released its decision dismissing both appeals. The Supreme Court was unanimous that the disposal effects were not in principle excluded from s 104(1)(a) assessment of 'effects'. However, the majority (Ellen France, Williams and Kós JJ) dismissed the appeal, while the minority (Winkelmann CJ and Glazebrook J) would have allowed the appeals and remitted the proposal to the Environment Court for reconsideration.
Majority Decision:
The majority held that the potential environmental effects of plastic bottle disposal were relevant “effects” within the meaning of s 104(1)(a) of the RMA (at [97]–[98]). In doing so, the majority considered two decisions relating to scope 3 (indirect) emissions in planning contexts: the New Zealand Supreme Court decision in West Coast ENT Inc v Buller Coal Ltd (Buller Coal), and the United Kingdom Supreme Court decision in R (on the application of Finch) v Surrey County Council (Finch). The majority in Buller Coal expressed a tentative view in obiter that scope 3 emissions’ effects may be outside the scope of s 104(1)(a) “effects” under the RMA.
The majority held that there can be “no hard and fast rule excluding indirect effects of allowing an activity- in other words, effects to which the applicant contributes but which occur only after some additional intervening act such as burning coal (Buller Coal) or oil (Finch)”. The majority also noted that the Buller Coal decision was careful not to express any concluded view on the question of whether scope 3 emissions engaged the general words of s 104(1)(a) of the RMA.
The majority also addressed the ‘third-party intervention argument’ finding that “the fact that third parties are responsible for disposing of the empty water bottles does not mean the effects of disposal are irrelevant to consenting for the production stage”. The majority found this was particularly the case if disposal is inevitable, being the case for water bottling - and found that this “is somewhat analogous to the circumstances in Finch and Buller Coal where the oil and coal would inevitably be burned by downstream purchasers—that was the point in buying it.”
The majority also rejected the ‘substitution’ argument raised by OSL (which was similarly raised in Buller Coal), where OSL had submitted that “controlling its production of plastic bottles serves no purpose…[because] if OSL did not produce the plastic bottles, another producer would (whether [in New Zealand] or offshore)”. The majority paraphrased this as “put another way, the argument is essentially that, in a global market, the absence of global controls makes local controls pointless” (at [78]). The majority found that “the substitutability argument focuses only on the potential for additional future harm; this all too conveniently ignores the producer’s share of existing harm”, and second, while there is a global market for bottled water, the plastics problem “is at once global, national and local” - and given this context “local regulatory initiatives may well have knock-on effects in other localities, at the national level or even globally”. Instead, the “management of environmental effects that have only in recent times become widely appreciated is likely to begin with incremental steps until a tipping point is reached”.
Ultimately, the majority found that not every effect will require consideration under that section, but identifying which effects are relevant is an exercise of statutory interpretation in light of facts (at [59]). The majority found that in the present case, there was nothing to suggest the environmental effects of plastic bottle disposal are irrelevant in principle; the real question is whether these effects are relevant in fact. There was, however, no evidence before the Environment Court upon which to make the required assessment one way or the other (at [99]).
Minority:
The minority judgment noted that “the science has changed since [the Buller Coal decision] and that many of the obiter comments made by the majority in Buller Coal in the context of climate change would not be supportable now” (at [247]). Touching on remoteness briefly, the minority decision also noted that in Buller Coal, the consents at issue were not permission to extract coal, but subsidiary consents relating to roads for a mine, and that “in that context, arguments about remoteness of climate change effects may possibly have more legs”.
- Climate Litigation Database
- /
- Search
- /
- New Zealand
- /
- Sustainable Otakiri Incorporated v Whakatāne District Council and Otakiri Springs Limited
Sustainable Otakiri Incorporated v Whakatāne District Council and Otakiri Springs Limited
About this case
Filing year
2020
Status
Decided
Geography
🇳🇿 New Zealand
Court/admin entity
New Zealand → Supreme Court of New Zealand
Case category
Suits against governments (Global) → Trade and Investment (Global) → Environmental permitting (Global)
Principal law
New Zealand → Resource Management Act 1991
Topics
, ,
Documents
Each case in our database can contain one or more documents.
Filing Date
Document
Type
Topics
11/12/2025
Sustainable Otakiri Incorporated v Whakatāne District Council and Otakiri Springs Limited - decision
Supreme Court of New Zealand decision by Chief Justice Helen Winklemann, Justice Susan Glazebrook, Justice Ellen France, Justice Joe Williams, and Justice Stephen Kós.
Decision
Fossil fuelCoalTrade sectorExtractive sector+ 37 more
04/17/2023
Sustainable Otakiri Incorporated v Whakatāne District Council and Otakiri Springs Limited - decision
Supreme Court of New Zealand application for leave decision by Justice Susan Glazebrook and Justice Mark O'Regan.
Decision
People with limited assetsFinance flowFreshwater adaptationWater adaptation+ 4 more
12/02/2022
Sustainable Otakiri Incorporated v Whakatāne District Council and Otakiri Springs Limited - decision
Court of Appeal decision by Judge Mark Cooper.
Decision
Trade sectorFossil fuelCoalExtractive sector+ 31 more
12/17/2020
Sustainable Otakiri Incorporated v Whakatāne District Council and Otakiri Springs Limited - decision
High Court decision by Judge Ian Gault.
Decision
Trade sectorFossil fuelCoalMarginalized ethnicity+ 32 more
Summary
Topics mentioned most in this case
See how often Topics get mentioned in this case and view specific passages of text highlighted in each document.
Group
Topics
Policy instrument
Risk
Impacted group
Just transition
Renewable energy
Fossil fuel
Greenhouse gas
Economic sector
Adaptation/resilience
Finance