Skip to content
The Climate Litigation Database

Association of Contracting Plumbers of the City of New York v. City of New York

About this case

Filing year
2023
Status
Decided
Geography
Docket number
25-977
Court/admin entity
United States → United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit (2d Cir.)United States → United States Federal Courts
Case category
Constitutional Claims (US) → Other Constitutional Claims (US)
Principal law
United States → Energy Policy and Conservation Act (EPCA)United States → Local LawsUnited States → New York City Local Law 154 of 2021United States → Supremacy Clause
At issue
Challenge to a New York City ordinance that prohibits combustion equipment with carbon dioxide emission levels over a certain threshold in new buildings.
Topics
, ,  

Documents

Each case in our database can contain one or more documents.

Filing Date
Document
Type
Topics
08/26/2026
Plaintiffs-appellants' petition for rehearing en banc denied.
On August 26, 2026, the Second Circuit Court of Appeals denied petitions for rehearing en banc of its opinion holding that the Energy Policy and Conservation Act (EPCA) did not preempt New York State and New York City building electrification requirements. Both petitions argued that rehearing en banc was warranted to rectify the circuit split created by the panel’s decision, which rejected the Ninth Circuit’s interpretation of California Restaurant Association v. City of Berkeley and also contradicted the federal government’s interpretation of EPCA. The petitions also argued that the panel decision was wrong because “EPCA’s plain text preempts the challenged bans because they effectively impose energy conservation standards that cap covered appliances’ energy use at zero.” The deadline for filing a petition for writ of certiorari in the U.S. Supreme Court is November 24, 2026.
Decision
Construction sector
07/28/2026
Petition for rehearing en banc filed by plaintiffs-appellants.
Challenge to a New York City ordinance that prohibits combustion equipment with carbon dioxide emission levels over a certain threshold in new buildings.
Petition For Rehearing
Fossil fuelBanGasCodes and standards+ 17 more
06/30/2026
Judgment for defendant City of New York affirmed.
The Second Circuit Court of Appeals held that the Energy Policy and Conservation Act (EPCA) did not preempt New York State and New York City laws that effectively prohibit use of fossil fuel-powered appliances in new buildings. The Second Circuit concluded that EPCA “does not directly regulate the availability of fossil-fuel-powered appliances, and its express preemption provision does not extend to laws far beyond its defined regulatory reach.” EPCA’s preemption provision provides that for a “covered product” for which an energy conservation standard has been established under EPCA, “no State regulation concerning the … energy use … of such covered product shall be effective with respect to such product.” The Second Circuit first concluded that the statutory definition of “energy use” and statutory context “make abundantly clear that the term refers to a metric determined before an appliance ever reaches consumers, not the energy that appliance uses in the hands of consumers”; the court therefore rejected the argument that the State and City laws were preempted because they effectively set fossil fuel-powered appliances’ “energy use” to zero. Second, the court held that the State and City laws were not regulations “concerning” the energy use of covered products. The court found that the challenged laws were not impermissibly connected to EPCA’s objectives “to establish a standardized set of performance standards for covered appliances to promote energy conservation. The court also found that the laws’ prohibition on use of certain covered appliances was not the kind of effect that created an impermissible connection. In addition, the Second Circuit concluded that the State and City laws did not reference or rely on an appliance’s “energy use.” The Second Circuit also rejected arguments asserted by the laws’ challengers based on the EPCA preemption provision’s title, EPCA’s definition of “energy conservation standard,” EPCA’s preemption exemption for certain building code regulations, and the history of the preemption provision. The Second Circuit also concluded that its interpretation avoided absurd results such as precluding a “whole slate of seemingly standard regulations” such as zoning laws that bar use of certain appliances in residential neighborhoods. The Second Circuit acknowledged that the Ninth Circuit had adopted a different interpretation of the EPCA preemption provision in California Restaurant Association v. City of Berkeley but stated that “the reasons for divergence” from the Ninth Circuit’s interpretation were “too compelling” and it was thus necessary to create a circuit split.
Decision
Fossil fuelCodes and standardsBanGas+ 15 more
11/06/2025
Brief filed by Sierra Club as amicus curiae supporting defendant-appellee.
Challenge to a New York City ordinance that prohibits combustion equipment with carbon dioxide emission levels over a certain threshold in new buildings.
Amicus Motion/Brief
Fossil fuelGasAir pollution riskGreenhouse gas+ 17 more
11/06/2025
Brief filed by District of Columbia and state and local governments as amici curiae in support of defendant-appellee and affirmance.
Challenge to a New York City ordinance that prohibits combustion equipment with carbon dioxide emission levels over a certain threshold in new buildings.
Amicus Motion/Brief
Fossil fuelCodes and standardsBanGas+ 16 more
11/06/2025
Brief filed by amicus curiae WE ACT for Environmental Justice in support of defendant-appellee.
Challenge to a New York City ordinance that prohibits combustion equipment with carbon dioxide emission levels over a certain threshold in new buildings.
Amicus Motion/Brief
Fossil fuelGasAir pollution riskBan+ 24 more
11/06/2025
Brief filed by the Guarini Center on Environmental, Energy and Land Use Law at N.Y.U. School of Law as amicus curiae in support of defendant-appellee and for affirmance.
Challenge to a New York City ordinance that prohibits combustion equipment with carbon dioxide emission levels over a certain threshold in new buildings.
Amicus Motion/Brief
Codes and standardsConstruction sectorFossil fuelGas+ 10 more
11/06/2025
Brief filed by amici curiae National League of Cities and the New York Conference of Mayors in support of defendant-appellee.
Challenge to a New York City ordinance that prohibits combustion equipment with carbon dioxide emission levels over a certain threshold in new buildings.
Amicus Motion/Brief
Fossil fuelGasCodes and standardsGreenhouse gas+ 23 more
11/06/2025
Brief filed by the Natural Resources Defense Council as amicus curiae supporting defendant-appellee.
Challenge to a New York City ordinance that prohibits combustion equipment with carbon dioxide emission levels over a certain threshold in new buildings.
Amicus Motion/Brief
Fossil fuelGasConstruction sectorCodes and standards+ 14 more
11/06/2025
Brief filed by amicus curiae Public Health Law Center supporting defendant-appellee and affirmance.
Challenge to a New York City ordinance that prohibits combustion equipment with carbon dioxide emission levels over a certain threshold in new buildings.
Amicus Motion/Brief
Codes and standardsFossil fuelGasAir pollution risk+ 16 more
10/30/2025
Brief filed by defendant-appellee.
Challenge to a New York City ordinance that prohibits combustion equipment with carbon dioxide emission levels over a certain threshold in new buildings.
Brief
Fossil fuelCodes and standardsBanConstruction sector+ 14 more
08/07/2025
Brief filed for United States as amicus curiae supporting appellants.
Challenge to a New York City ordinance that prohibits combustion equipment with carbon dioxide emission levels over a certain threshold in new buildings.
Amicus Motion/Brief
BanFossil fuelCodes and standardsGas+ 20 more
07/31/2025
Brief filed by plaintiffs-appellants.
Challenge to a New York City ordinance that prohibits combustion equipment with carbon dioxide emission levels over a certain threshold in new buildings.
Brief
BanFossil fuelGasCodes and standards+ 26 more

Summary

Challenge to a New York City ordinance that prohibits combustion equipment with carbon dioxide emission levels over a certain threshold in new buildings.

 Topics mentioned most in this case

See how often Topics get mentioned in this case and view specific passages of text highlighted in each document.

Group
Topics
Target
Policy instrument
Risk
Impacted group
Just transition
Renewable energy
Fossil fuel
Greenhouse gas
Economic sector
Adaptation/resilience
Finance